[ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Butuh saran untuk membeli kendaraan untuk pribadi, keluarga ataupun kerja? Silakan dibahas disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

User avatar
silverant
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 6:54
Location: Jakarta

[ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by silverant »

Dear SerayaMotor members,


Salam kenal, mobil saya saat ini adalah honda city 2006 Vtec, Automatic, beli second tahun lalu. Karena sekarang anak sudah dua, dan kebetulan adik-adik saya berada di Jakarta, juga Ibu saya sering ke Jakarta, kadang2 kalo pengin jalan kerasa ga cukup mobilnya.

Saat ini kalo dipaksakan sih masih cukup, karena anak saya masih umur 2 tahun dan 3 bulan, jadi posisinya, sopir, sebelah sopir + pangku anak umur 2 tahun, belakang istri saya gendong anak 3 bulan, ibu saya dan kemudian adik saya. So far masih ok buat tenaga (karena ga terlalu suka kebut2an juga) cuma jelas kurang nyaman (sempit).

So lagi ngincer mpv secondhand, pertimbangannya, mobil second yg kelas lebih baik rasanya kok masih lebih bagus fiturnya daripada mobil baru di harga yg sama (mohon masukannya jika ada pandangan lain).

Mobil sangat jarang dipake, weekend pun blm tentu keluar, kemarin ganti oli mesin pun pas 1 tahun pas kilometernya.
Kemarin-kemarin pake premiun buat city, tapi kalo harganya deket seperti sekarang, mungkin pake pertamax juga ok, atau solar jg gpp.

Budget max 150 jt.

Yang kebayang adalah kijang inova 2004/2005, atau avanza.
Tadi pagi ditawarin CR-V, tapi masih agak diluar budget (padahal pengin banget mobil ini :D )


Ada saran buat mobil mpv yg kira-kira cocok buat saya ?

Thanks :)
adty
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 932
Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2014 2:06

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by adty »

Coba nissan serena C24 CT/HWS tahun 2006 kebawah kayaknya udah sesuai budget. Mobilnya nyaman, lega, pintu udah sliding door dan tarikan bawahnya enak. Konsekuensinya ini mobil boros, dalkot bisa 1:5-1:6an. Tapi karena jarang dipake jadi its okay go for serena. Enak buat ramai2 sama keluarga.

Oya harus spend budget karena serena cukup rewel compared to innova *pengalaman pake C24 hampir 10 tahun*
Penikmat roti tawar beroda
User avatar
htannis
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3287
Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:36

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by htannis »

sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
STREET RACING IN A 4xx whp/1xxx nm atw in a 3050cc DIESEL MPV IS NOT A CRIME
well it is, but who cares
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by montirangin »

htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
kalo sama captiva mending mana om htannis?
liep
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1670
Joined: Fri Feb 14, 2014 8:01

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by liep »

apapun kebutuhan anda, mobil apapun yg anda bandingkan, buat om htannis, innova d4d a/t adl jawabannya, hehehe
montirangin wrote:
htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
kalo sama captiva mending mana om htannis?
unthul
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 108
Joined: Thu Jan 02, 2014 3:11
Location: semarang

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by unthul »

htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
:mky_02: derek om htannis ah...


*balikmacullagi
eling..dan bersyukur..
lemonadelovers
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1704
Joined: Sat Apr 26, 2014 4:42

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by lemonadelovers »

innova bensin 2004/2005 belum euro 2 bensinya lebih boros, avanza cari yang veloz om ABS+ airbag (2013up) om soalnya penting utk mobil keluarga. Atau coba stream saja facelift 2005-2007, bisa ambil yg 2.0 (fitur lengkap ABS Airbag Immobilizer) dr budget om masih ada sisa uang utk ditabung/ maintenance
Big Displacement V engine enthusiast:
V8: 1UR-FSE{|}8AT
V6: 2GR-FE{|}6AT
V6: G6DF{|}6AT

Eco Mode
DDiS 1.3
1NR-VE
K10C
iamwewe
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1173
Joined: Thu Jun 14, 2012 3:39
Location: jakarta

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by iamwewe »

htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
yes, saya juga stuju nih. innova d4d matic, jozzzzz
User avatar
silverant
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 6:54
Location: Jakarta

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by silverant »

adty wrote:Coba nissan serena C24 CT/HWS tahun 2006 kebawah kayaknya udah sesuai budget. Mobilnya nyaman, lega, pintu udah sliding door dan tarikan bawahnya enak. Konsekuensinya ini mobil boros, dalkot bisa 1:5-1:6an. Tapi karena jarang dipake jadi its okay go for serena. Enak buat ramai2 sama keluarga.

Oya harus spend budget karena serena cukup rewel compared to innova *pengalaman pake C24 hampir 10 tahun*
Wah serena boros juga ya, kalo 1:5 mayan juga, rencana mobil dipake juga buat mudik ke Jawa mungkin 2 kali setahun..

Humm, kalo agak rewel sebenarnya kurang suka Om, karena mobil jarang dipake masa weekend malah ke bengkel, penginnya weekend buat jalan aja :D

Tapi thanks buat masukannya, kemarin memang sempat compare serena juga, tapi baru tau kalo konsumsi bensinnya mirip ama innova (innova bensin dalkot sekitar 1:5-6 juga kata teman saya). Tadinya saya kira serena lebih irit (1:7-8) ...

htannis wrote: sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
harga jual innova second yg matic katanya lebih rendah ya Om ? kalo harganya lebih rendah, saya jelas pilih matic nya :)

Oh ya nanya, matic nya Innova ini lebih mirip ke maticnya Honda city atau ke Avanza ya ?

Maticnya honda city kan cvt ya, jadi ga kerasa perpindahan giginya.


Thanks a lot :)
adty
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 932
Joined: Thu Sep 04, 2014 2:06

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by adty »

Rewel serena maksudnya kalo dipake mobile banget kok, kalo jarang2 sih nggak. Yes memang borosnya mungkin 11:12 sama innova awal, tp nyamannya bikin keluarga betah jalan jauh :mky_03:

*bukan seles batumakam*
Penikmat roti tawar beroda
User avatar
silverant
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 6:54
Location: Jakarta

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by silverant »

liep wrote:apapun kebutuhan anda, mobil apapun yg anda bandingkan, buat om htannis, innova d4d a/t adl jawabannya, hehehe
montirangin wrote:
htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
kalo sama captiva mending mana om htannis?

Hahaha gitu ya :mky_01:
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by DOHC »

silverant wrote:
harga jual innova second yg matic katanya lebih rendah ya Om ? kalo harganya lebih rendah, saya jelas pilih matic nya :)

Oh ya nanya, matic nya Innova ini lebih mirip ke maticnya Honda city atau ke Avanza ya ?

Maticnya honda city kan cvt ya, jadi ga kerasa perpindahan giginya.


Thanks a lot :)
matic nya ipah apalagi yg bensin itu lemot dan perpindahan gigi agak terasa... tp ini matic robust... sangat kuat disiksa dan dibejeg abis2an... ane perna disupirin naek ipah bensin gen 1 nya pejabat pemkot setempat... ntuh ipah matic odo uda tembus 200 rbu, cara nyetir supir nya pun macam supir travel antar propinsi sulawesi... lampu merah start di 3 trus geser ke D... sspanjang nyetir jg tuh tangan ga berhenti2 geser kiri kanan antara D dan 3.... fine2 aja... mnurut sang supir, blom perna overhaul dan cuman ngikutin saran servis di hadji kalla toyota aj, per 40 rebu kuras...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
sandal
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3701
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2014 1:13

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by sandal »

Jelas saran om htannis lah.... Innova D4D AT tipe V kalo bisa (syukur2 kalo dapet tahun 2004/2005 ke atas :mky_01: )

Atau coba Avanza 1.5 S AT juga.... (tapi lupa tahun berapa :mky_01: :big_slap: )
There is no past nor future, only now - Nathan MLBB

2017 TM2FX MT

2022 NF11T11C01 MT
User avatar
htannis
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3287
Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:36

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by htannis »

montirangin wrote:
htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
kalo sama captiva mending mana om htannis?
jauh lah, innova atuh, harga lebih murah, kabin lebih gede, mesin, suspensi dll bisa di custom sesuai kebutuhan :ngacir:
STREET RACING IN A 4xx whp/1xxx nm atw in a 3050cc DIESEL MPV IS NOT A CRIME
well it is, but who cares
User avatar
htannis
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3287
Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:36

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by htannis »

liep wrote:apapun kebutuhan anda, mobil apapun yg anda bandingkan, buat om htannis, innova d4d a/t adl jawabannya, hehehe
montirangin wrote:
htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
kalo sama captiva mending mana om htannis?

nah pinter, ane kasih cendol yah gan :ngacir:
STREET RACING IN A 4xx whp/1xxx nm atw in a 3050cc DIESEL MPV IS NOT A CRIME
well it is, but who cares
User avatar
htannis
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3287
Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2011 7:36

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by htannis »

silverant wrote:
adty wrote:Coba nissan serena C24 CT/HWS tahun 2006 kebawah kayaknya udah sesuai budget. Mobilnya nyaman, lega, pintu udah sliding door dan tarikan bawahnya enak. Konsekuensinya ini mobil boros, dalkot bisa 1:5-1:6an. Tapi karena jarang dipake jadi its okay go for serena. Enak buat ramai2 sama keluarga.

Oya harus spend budget karena serena cukup rewel compared to innova *pengalaman pake C24 hampir 10 tahun*
Wah serena boros juga ya, kalo 1:5 mayan juga, rencana mobil dipake juga buat mudik ke Jawa mungkin 2 kali setahun..

Humm, kalo agak rewel sebenarnya kurang suka Om, karena mobil jarang dipake masa weekend malah ke bengkel, penginnya weekend buat jalan aja :D

Tapi thanks buat masukannya, kemarin memang sempat compare serena juga, tapi baru tau kalo konsumsi bensinnya mirip ama innova (innova bensin dalkot sekitar 1:5-6 juga kata teman saya). Tadinya saya kira serena lebih irit (1:7-8) ...

htannis wrote: sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
harga jual innova second yg matic katanya lebih rendah ya Om ? kalo harganya lebih rendah, saya jelas pilih matic nya :)

Oh ya nanya, matic nya Innova ini lebih mirip ke maticnya Honda city atau ke Avanza ya ?

Maticnya honda city kan cvt ya, jadi ga kerasa perpindahan giginya.


Thanks a lot :)
harga jual innova matic untik yg diesel lebih tinggi daripada yg manual, beda dengan versi bensinnya. untuk matic innova diesel itu spec sama dengan matic toyota supra 3000cc twinturbo makanya kuat sekali, yg terakhir kemarin saya cobain innoca d4d temen 500hp++ boost 50 psi dengan kondisi matic std hanya diupgrade bodyvalve nya supaya gak selip. kondisi std sih maticnya halus banget, kl dah diupgrade bodyvalve nya yah jadi lbh kasar jauh
STREET RACING IN A 4xx whp/1xxx nm atw in a 3050cc DIESEL MPV IS NOT A CRIME
well it is, but who cares
User avatar
silverant
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 94
Joined: Mon Sep 16, 2013 6:54
Location: Jakarta

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by silverant »

lemonadelovers wrote:innova bensin 2004/2005 belum euro 2 bensinya lebih boros, avanza cari yang veloz om ABS+ airbag (2013up) om soalnya penting utk mobil keluarga. Atau coba stream saja facelift 2005-2007, bisa ambil yg 2.0 (fitur lengkap ABS Airbag Immobilizer) dr budget om masih ada sisa uang utk ditabung/ maintenance
stream 2005-2007 dapet ya Om kalo 150... ?
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by montirangin »

masa iya sih matic lebih murah dari manual? untuk 2005 dan sebelum atau khususnya 2000 dan sebelum memang iya, namun setelah itu kalo mobilnya yg medium keatas rasanya udah ga deh. Maksudnya maticnya lebih mahal.
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by amfibi »

silverant wrote:
lemonadelovers wrote:innova bensin 2004/2005 belum euro 2 bensinya lebih boros, avanza cari yang veloz om ABS+ airbag (2013up) om soalnya penting utk mobil keluarga. Atau coba stream saja facelift 2005-2007, bisa ambil yg 2.0 (fitur lengkap ABS Airbag Immobilizer) dr budget om masih ada sisa uang utk ditabung/ maintenance
stream 2005-2007 dapet ya Om kalo 150... ?
Dapet om :mky_02:

Ane juga saran stream aja, mobilnya enak kok, FC juga ga gt boros sebanding sama tenaganya, drpd innova bensin boros iya boyo juga iya...

yg jelas ga bikin sakit pinggang kaya city vtec 05 yg ane pake sehari hari :mky_03:
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by amfibi »

Oiya, kalo emag mau banget innova, bisa dapet G bensin taun 08-09 :mky_01:
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by montirangin »

kalo mau ambil stream, di test jalan, check steering racknya juga.
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by DOHC »

amfibi wrote:Oiya, kalo emag mau banget innova, bisa dapet G bensin taun 08-09 :mky_01:
jgn dehh..

udahh.. ipah d4d aj kl matic....

bsa nangis lemot nya ipah bensin matic... apalagi beralih dr matic vtec sedan...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
Turboman
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 22072
Joined: Mon Dec 12, 2005 5:14

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by Turboman »

Utk Ipah yg layak dipinang ya either D4 D atau 2.7 - 2TR-Fe (kalo demen yg Gasoline)

Mmg sih Ipah ini skg sudah jadi mobil hobby, segala macam add-on / Performance parts-nya banyak sekali, mulai dr mesin / suspensi hingga rem

Kalo motto saya :
Se-bagus2-nya sebuah mobil dalam kondisi std, pasti ada aja yg kurang

Se-jelek2-nya mobil dalam kondisi std, dengan adanya "add on upgrade parts" maka bisa dibikin nyaman / Powerfull

Jadi mobil yg banyak "add-on Perf parts"-nya tentu lebih fun utk dimiliki, ketimbang mobil yg std-nya udah bagus tapi gak bisa di apa2-in (what a boring)......terlepas dari type & mereknya
* Bukan ajakan Beli *
User avatar
nugroho bagor
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5507
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2011 22:48
Location: All over the world
Daily Vehicle: Kijang Innova D4D

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by nugroho bagor »

htannis wrote:sudah pasti innova d4d a/t lah.
mpv worth every money you spend :mky_01:
Yes,roger That sir,BLT ala om Turboman,sudah nyaman
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: [ASK] Want to Switch from Honda City to MPV

Post by montirangin »

Turboman wrote:Utk Ipah yg layak dipinang ya either D4 D atau 2.7 - 2TR-Fe (kalo demen yg Gasoline)

Mmg sih Ipah ini skg sudah jadi mobil hobby, segala macam add-on / Performance parts-nya banyak sekali, mulai dr mesin / suspensi hingga rem

Kalo motto saya :
Se-bagus2-nya sebuah mobil dalam kondisi std, pasti ada aja yg kurang

Se-jelek2-nya mobil dalam kondisi std, dengan adanya "add on upgrade parts" maka bisa dibikin nyaman / Powerfull

Jadi mobil yg banyak "add-on Perf parts"-nya tentu lebih fun utk dimiliki, ketimbang mobil yg std-nya udah bagus tapi gak bisa di apa2-in (what a boring)......terlepas dari type & mereknya
ini namanya ga puas om :big_peace: