Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit
Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Mungkin SUV2 besar skrg udah mau masuk kategori dinosaurus...agak ketinggalan jaman di era irit bahan bakar..tapi lihat video ini...
http://www.autoblog.com/2008/07/28/vide ... -who-wins/
http://www.autoblog.com/2008/07/28/vide ... -who-wins/
-
- Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 2610
- Joined: Sat Apr 14, 2007 15:01
- Location: Kemanggisan, Jakarta Barat
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Meskipun menggunakan platform yang sama... kenapa Q7 kelihatan lebih besar dari Touareg ya?
Jangan-2 Q7 itu,,, metromini diganti casing....????
Jangan-2 Q7 itu,,, metromini diganti casing....????
Dari Solo ke Oslo
-
- Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 1640
- Joined: Sat Mar 20, 2004 17:59
- Location: in the globe
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Gila,ngeri bgt yah 'impact' dari side to side accident ini yah?
Biasanya utk test gini speednya berapa?40 kpj?
Bener2 menunjukkan efek crumple zone di Audi,tetapi ruang penumpang tetap safe walaupun bagian depan mobil remuk..
Biasanya utk test gini speednya berapa?40 kpj?
Bener2 menunjukkan efek crumple zone di Audi,tetapi ruang penumpang tetap safe walaupun bagian depan mobil remuk..
Avanza@2006>>>
Innova@2010>>>
EcoSport@2014 >>>
Black VRZ@2016
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Bukan cuman crumple zone Audi saja, sebenernya ini udah ilmu fisika. Coba Audi Q7 lawan truk ala Tansformers (18-wheeler), pasti gak selamat yg di Audi.
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
ternyata AUdi(besar) dan FIat(kecil) nya hampir sama2 parah...
-
- Full Member of Senior Mechanic
- Posts: 438
- Joined: Sat May 05, 2007 5:48
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Keknya kalo orang beneran
Drivernya fiat patah kaki ama kepalanya banyak benjolnya deh
Drivernya fiat patah kaki ama kepalanya banyak benjolnya deh
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Yang jelas sih head injury parahlucky_strike_21 wrote:Keknya kalo orang beneran
Drivernya fiat patah kaki ama kepalanya banyak benjolnya deh
-
- New Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 1261
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 15:00
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
smart
tapi coba check yang ini ; mungkin udah pernah liat (70 Mph) : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju6t-yyoU8s
Wah, itu seperti ngadu Fortuner lawan Jazz..FortunerMan wrote:Mungkin SUV2 besar skrg udah mau masuk kategori dinosaurus...agak ketinggalan jaman di era irit bahan bakar..tapi lihat video ini...
http://www.autoblog.com/2008/07/28/vide ... -who-wins/
tapi coba check yang ini ; mungkin udah pernah liat (70 Mph) : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju6t-yyoU8s
Lagi nginjek rem..
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
kalo fortuner nabrak apa aja yah pasti yg ditabrak parah kondisinya, bisa2 termasuk adu banteng dgn Q7 (or Touareg) yg notabene kalo liat dari video tsb Q7 emang dibikin sangat crumple (body)....
-
- Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 14333
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
- Location: jakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
wah.. koq airbag di fiat pada bagian driver mengempis lg?
secrumple body fiat, tp klo lawannya Q7..
secrumple body fiat, tp klo lawannya Q7..
Permisii .............................
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
justru mindset di video tsb bermaksud memperlihatkan diluar ekspektasi awam...
Q7 pun kurang lebih sama kondisinya dgn fiat.. krn fiat kecil agak "menerobos ke dalam" Q7.
keduanya cukup "crumple".. apalagi Q7 kompartemen mesinnya kontan pecah2 berhamburan kemana2.
Q7 pun kurang lebih sama kondisinya dgn fiat.. krn fiat kecil agak "menerobos ke dalam" Q7.
keduanya cukup "crumple".. apalagi Q7 kompartemen mesinnya kontan pecah2 berhamburan kemana2.
-
- Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 14333
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
- Location: jakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
i see.. iya sih, ke2-nya memang "crumple" terlihat waktu di slow motion..
hmm.. coba kalau q7 versus range rover... gmana yah?
hmm.. coba kalau q7 versus range rover... gmana yah?
Permisii .............................
-
- Full Member of Senior Mechanic
- Posts: 483
- Joined: Thu Mar 23, 2006 4:10
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
afaik semua langsung kempes kok (untuk meredam impact kepala kita)nescafe wrote:wah.. koq airbag di fiat pada bagian driver mengempis lg?
kalo kenceng terus, ya impact nya tetep keras dong.
saya dulu tabrakan, langsung deployed, langsung instantly kempes juga abis kepala saya mental ke airbag
my ride: MB G300
http://serayamotor.com/diskusi/viewtopi ... 99&start=0
http://serayamotor.com/diskusi/viewtopi ... 99&start=0
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5870
- Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 4:21
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
yg seru itu G class lawan Hummer H1.nescafe wrote:
hmm.. coba kalau q7 versus range rover... gmana yah?
Menang mana tuh?
-
- Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 14333
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
- Location: jakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
ooh.. i see.. tak kira karena ada kesalahan teknis.. thanks bos shocushochu wrote:afaik semua langsung kempes kok (untuk meredam impact kepala kita)nescafe wrote:wah.. koq airbag di fiat pada bagian driver mengempis lg?
kalo kenceng terus, ya impact nya tetep keras dong.
saya dulu tabrakan, langsung deployed, langsung instantly kempes juga abis kepala saya mental ke airbag
Permisii .............................
-
- Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 1643
- Joined: Thu Apr 19, 2007 6:15
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Bro, gimana kalo salah satu member di SM ini jg pake kamera, trus direkam hasil crash test mobil mobil berikut ini, lsg ditabrakan head to head aja bro:
- Chery QQ vs. Bajaj
- Chery QQ vs. Ceria
- Avanza vs. Livina
- Kijang vs. Grand Livina
- Grand Max vs. APV
- Chery QQ vs. Bajaj
- Chery QQ vs. Ceria
- Avanza vs. Livina
- Kijang vs. Grand Livina
- Grand Max vs. APV
-
- New Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 8285
- Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 19:52
- Location: djakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
nampaknya mindset nya bukan utk menunjukkan diluar ekspektasi awam,.. tp justru menguatkan anggapan awam, yaitu:GTR wrote:justru mindset di video tsb bermaksud memperlihatkan diluar ekspektasi awam...MitshuToyo wrote:Wah, itu seperti ngadu Fortuner lawan Jazz..FortunerMan wrote: http://www.autoblog.com/2008/07/28/vide ... -who-wins/
Mungkin SUV2 besar skrg udah mau masuk kategori dinosaurus...agak ketinggalan jaman di era irit bahan bakar..tapi lihat video ini...
Q7 pun kurang lebih sama kondisinya dgn fiat.. krn fiat kecil agak "menerobos ke dalam" Q7.
regardless teknologi safety (massal) yg diusungnya, hukum dasarnya adalah tetap: makin besar (berat), makin menang (safe).
spt apa yg dibilang (diekspresikan) oleh bro FM, dan bro MT di atas...
yg intinya: "folks, you may bikin any (bad) comments apapun ttg si gambot Fortuner yg lelet, kuno layaknya dinosaurus, plus gak efisien, ..... and you may mendewakan mobil kecil yg praktis, safe, dan semakin menjadi trend skrg ini...... tp, bagaimanapun, dlm situasi tabrakan, this big-size (and heavy) SUV tetaplah worth it."
spt juga yg ditulis di video itu (gw kutip):
"Automakers will tell you that their new go-karts get five stars in crash tests and that they're as safe as ever.
But wouldn't you like to see what would happen if a three-ton SUV hit one of these miniature motor vehicles?"
Last edited by andy1800 on Mon Aug 04, 2008 9:50, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
oo.. i c... ada tulisan nya itu.
tapi paling "rule" ya itu "SUV" kuno macam TAFT-feroza or MPV ya phanter(hi-sporty)... even vs big SUV modern macam fortuner kali ya... krn struktur body nya masih lebih "keras"...
Btw, Stars crash-test bukannya juga means "pedestarian safe" yah.
tapi paling "rule" ya itu "SUV" kuno macam TAFT-feroza or MPV ya phanter(hi-sporty)... even vs big SUV modern macam fortuner kali ya... krn struktur body nya masih lebih "keras"...
Btw, Stars crash-test bukannya juga means "pedestarian safe" yah.
Last edited by GTR on Mon Aug 04, 2008 9:53, edited 1 time in total.
-
- New Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 8285
- Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 19:52
- Location: djakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
iya.
bro, bikin crash test yuk ....
mobil dg body besi nan berat: Land Cruiser Long Wheelbase FJ brapa itu ya yang Hardtop, membawa emas batangan dua ton....lawan Fortuner
apa jadinya ya??...
......
heuhehehehe
bro, bikin crash test yuk ....
mobil dg body besi nan berat: Land Cruiser Long Wheelbase FJ brapa itu ya yang Hardtop, membawa emas batangan dua ton....lawan Fortuner
apa jadinya ya??...
......
heuhehehehe
Last edited by andy1800 on Mon Aug 04, 2008 9:58, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
ga sekalian vs tata nano... .
-
- Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 14333
- Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
- Location: jakarta
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
atau lawan becak seperti di thread sebelah..
Permisii .............................
-
- New Member of Mechanic Master
- Posts: 9595
- Joined: Thu May 15, 2003 16:12
- Location: Indonesia
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
Biasanya untuk frontal crash test di kisaran 60-65km/h, untuk side crash test dikisaran 30-35km/hedward wrote:Gila,ngeri bgt yah 'impact' dari side to side accident ini yah?
Biasanya utk test gini speednya berapa?40 kpj?
Bener2 menunjukkan efek crumple zone di Audi,tetapi ruang penumpang tetap safe walaupun bagian depan mobil remuk..
Saya pernah liat review crash test, mobil jip, suv atau yg lebih tinggi umumnya lebih aman.
-
- Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
- Posts: 5168
- Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
iya, makanya CRV dst model lainnya, walaupun bodynya tinggi, bumper nya tetep dibuat serendah mungkin, agar klo bisa sama "rendah hati" nya dgn siapapun terutama yg lebih kecil di jalan....
-
- Member of Junior Mechanic
- Posts: 55
- Joined: Sat Sep 13, 2008 13:52
Re: Why Big SUVs rule the world (Fiat 500 vs Audi Q7)
seperti nya sih CACAT omTiongBahru_Ahbeng wrote:Bro, gimana kalo salah satu member di SM ini jg pake kamera, trus direkam hasil crash test mobil mobil berikut ini, lsg ditabrakan head to head aja bro:
- Chery QQ vs. Bajaj
- Chery QQ vs. Ceria
- Avanza vs. Livina
- Kijang vs. Grand Livina
- Grand Max vs. APV
...........