Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Butuh saran untuk membeli kendaraan untuk pribadi, keluarga ataupun kerja? Silakan dibahas disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

kerubim
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 44
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 10:52

Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by kerubim »

saat ini saya pake terios manual 2012, nah mau ambil mobil matic dengan budget 150 jt.
Sehari hari penumpang 2 orang atau kalau week end paling ber 4. (Tambah batita + suster).

Rute yang dilewatin bsd - sudirman paling kalau liburan mentok2 ke bandung aja.

Minta masukan dong paling worthied ambil yang mana yah? Pertimbangan:
1. Build quality
2. Gak gampang gasruk (sekarang bawa terios soalnya aman)
3. Gak ngerepotin, perawatan selama ini taunya ke beres aja.
4. Kenyamanan dan kepraktisan.
Yonatanw
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 271
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2016 10:43
Location: Surabaya

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by Yonatanw »

IMHO, kalau di jazz yang enak supirnya om.. kalau ertiga yang enak penumpangnya..

1.) menang ertiga
2.) jazz gampang gasruk
3.) dua dua ga ada yang repotin. Jazz saya 4 taon, taunya beres saja. Suzuki sdh pasti ga repotin, asal jangan rusak part yang slow moving.
4.) Nyaman ertiga.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
DD4 CVT | GE8 5AT | K3-VE
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16683
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by ChZ »

Dari Terios kedua duanya enak koq... tapi kalo buat sesekali ke luar kota ya mungkin Ertiga lebih cocok buat insidentil.

Kalo manual mungkin enak. Kalo matic yaaa asal gak bermasalah dengan tarikan lelet gak ada yang salah sih dari mobil ini.
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
User avatar
BrianK3
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 204
Joined: Mon Sep 28, 2015 16:10
Daily Vehicle: VW Tiguan 2014

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by BrianK3 »

Kalau sudah berkeluarga dan ini mobil satu2-nya, saya lebih saranin ambil yang ada 3 baris. Jauh lebih practical karena pasti ada saja pemain extra yang mau naik mobil kita.
VW Tiguan TSI Highline 2014
Honda HR-V SE 2024
aabx
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 301
Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2009 9:03
Location: Batavia

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by aabx »

poin nomor 2 dan 4, Honda Jazz udah kalah telak
mr_mytplx
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1327
Joined: Mon Apr 20, 2009 6:17

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by mr_mytplx »

Ane prefer ertiga om. Kl bisa yg sebelom facelift, yg masih dpt abs ama mukanya belom anrh.

Sent from my LT26i using Seraya Motor mobile app
kerubim
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 44
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 10:52

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by kerubim »

Banyak yang dukung ke ertiga nih...

Kalau jazz mau ninggiin GC bisa gak sih? Harus pake coilover gt yah kayaknya dan mihul...

Sebenernya ada 1 kandidat lagi sih, grandis gt 2010, naksir sama model dan kepraktisan nya. Sayang udh discotinued, takut ribet sparepart nya
doge
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 795
Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2016 14:54

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by doge »

kerubim wrote:Banyak yang dukung ke ertiga nih...

Kalau jazz mau ninggiin GC bisa gak sih? Harus pake coilover gt yah kayaknya dan mihul...

Sebenernya ada 1 kandidat lagi sih, grandis gt 2010, naksir sama model dan kepraktisan nya. Sayang udh discotinued, takut ribet sparepart nya
Ya bisa sih... tp kan ya aneh... biasanya jazz itu malah dikandasin wkwkwk
Klo naikin gc mobil itu ntar jd agak limbung mobilnya... krn center gravitynya naik..
Coilover bwt jazz setauku bs nya nyeperin.. gtw klo bs ngelift dikit
Drpd repot mending cri yg bawaan gc nya agak tinggi...
:ngacir:
Yonatanw
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 271
Joined: Sun Feb 21, 2016 10:43
Location: Surabaya

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by Yonatanw »

IMHO, Sebenernya GC ertiga juga ngga tinggi2 amat sih..

Jazz :
+ power besar
+ stabil
+ handling mantab
- build quality, terutama peredam kolong
- Suspensi cenderung keras

Ertiga
+ nyaman
+ empuk
+ build quality baik
- body roll kerasa
- mbl terasa ringan


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
DD4 CVT | GE8 5AT | K3-VE
adiguna
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 159
Joined: Sun Sep 19, 2010 0:28

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by adiguna »

Rundeer wrote:
luginar wrote:Kenapa tidak brio yg baru saja? Tapi kalau kekeh pengen yg second ya jazz lah.

Ertiga kaki kaki lemah, gampang rusak, sparepart mahal. Boyo banget sama carry aja 11-12 itu mobil
Siapa bilang carry boyo? Angkot carry isi full load 12 org aja masih bisa ngebut :ngacir: :ngacir:
Hahaa....jadi inget lagi, dulu thn 90an kita dikampung kalo abis lebaran hampir pasti kudu pergi ke tempat rekreasi ( piknik lah istilah kita dulu mah..), nah mobilnya cmn ada suzuki carry punya sodara yg 1000 cc yg lampunya masih bulet gak tau thn brp tuh carry, pdhl keluarga besar kita ada 12 orang ya udah terpaksa bikin bangku dibelakang sopir dan bisa didudukin 3 orang berhadap hadapan sama orang yg duduk di row kedua trus didepan 3 orang jadi deh muat 12 orang...hahaa, Pergi ke ciwidey yg nanjak terus dan hebatnya tuh carry masih bisa ngebut nyalip bbrp mobil didepan.....karena sopirnya stress dikomplen mulu ama penumpangnya yg ibu2 gendut2 yg kesempitan dibelakang...hihii
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by DOHC »

itu asal njeplak banget yah yg blg carry boyo... brio isi 5 orang aj ud bengek2 nanjak di cisarua... masi brani bandingin ama carry ceceng, isi penuh aj masi bsa ngadu ama mobil2 pelat B...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
diodio
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 41
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2014 10:20

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by diodio »

Dari point satu sampai empat lebih condong ke r3. Buntut ertiga juga ga panjang banget, masih serasa bawa buntut hatchback. Pake selama tiga tahun ga pernah rewel, isi bensin ganti oli aja. Pake akap panties kadang suka lewat bahu jalan kalo macet, ga pernah/jarang nyangkut, gc masih toleransi aman. Perhatikan speed saja
diodio
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 41
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2014 10:20

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by diodio »

Dari point satu sampai empat lebih condong ke r3. Buntut ertiga juga ga panjang banget, masih serasa bawa buntut hatchback. Pake selama tiga tahun ga pernah rewel, isi bensin ganti oli aja. Pake akap kadang suka lewat bahu jalan kalo macet, ga pernah/jarang nyangkut, gc masih toleransi aman. Perhatikan speed saja
shoepatu
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 295
Joined: Wed Sep 24, 2014 15:13

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by shoepatu »

DOHC wrote:itu asal njeplak banget yah yg blg carry boyo... brio isi 5 orang aj ud bengek2 nanjak di cisarua... masi brani bandingin ama carry ceceng, isi penuh aj masi bsa ngadu ama mobil2 pelat B...

Blm diceperin tuh ya carry nya,di ciwidey tuh carry yg angkut 12orang naik turun tanjakan hahahha
User avatar
sandal
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3701
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2014 1:13

Re: RE: Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by sandal »

DOHC wrote:itu asal njeplak banget yah yg blg carry boyo... brio isi 5 orang aj ud bengek2 nanjak di cisarua... masi brani bandingin ama carry ceceng, isi penuh aj masi bsa ngadu ama mobil2 pelat B...
Carry2 ala angkot apalagi tuh :mky_03:

:ngacir:

Sent from my SM-G7102 using Seraya Motor mobile app
There is no past nor future, only now - Nathan MLBB

2017 TM2FX MT

2022 NF11T11C01 MT
walid_007
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3209
Joined: Sat Mar 30, 2013 0:52
Location: idn, 18 mdpl
Daily Vehicle: b48 1gd 4a9

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by walid_007 »

Ngak dua2 nya, pilih sj innova
engine roaring!
arfyano
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 264
Joined: Tue Oct 06, 2015 0:59
Location: Bogor
Daily Vehicle: Mitsubishi Pajero Sport 4x4 Limited

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by arfyano »

Kl pilihannya cm 2 itu ya ane vote ertiga.. jazz enak utk nyetir, kl si om ga sering bwa penumpang full sih g mslh. Enak utk harian dpke kerja, tp kl srg bwa klrga ya krg enak, sempit dblkng. Kebetulan nykp pke yg RS 2013,, kaki2 nya gluduk2 kl ada jln gelombang. Tp kl bwt ngebut d tol asik

Sent from my Lenovo K920 using Seraya Motor mobile app
Pboyz97
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 4913
Joined: Sun Oct 09, 2016 15:14
Location: East Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: BRV Prestige Non HS 2023 - AN HRV SE 2023

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by Pboyz97 »

vote for ertiga elegant
soalnya punya built quality paling baik diantara rival sekelasnya , bensin lumayan irit & desainnya lumayan bagus kalo menurut saya + bisa muat 7 orang sehingga memenuhi kriteria no 2&4. Kalo jazz menang no 3 sih kalo menurut saya, karena nama besar Honda , gampang disetir (fun to drive) + handling & peforma terbaik di kelasnya belom lagi kelegaan kabin baris ke2 & kepraktisan yg juga terbaik di kelasnya, sayangnya kurang cocok kalo buat ke luar kota, karena gampang gasruk kalo diisi full load + bensinnya yg lumayan boros (dalkot) buat sebuah hatchback 1500CC kalo menurut saya ditambah lagi bq yg ga sebaik rival2 sekelasnya serta nyari unitnya yg lumayan susah kalo dibandingin tipe RS karena tipe S kurang diminati penjualannya dibanding tipe RS.
Past:
'09 GE8
'10 CRV RE
'13 CX5
'17 Xpander
'19 Yaris
'18 CX5
'18 ANF 2GD
'18 HRV
'18 ANKI 2GD
'19 CRV
'14 GNKI 1TR
'22 brio
'18 RX300
'18 ANPS
Now:
'23 voxy
'23 BRV
'23 HRV
'24 U11
Maruti
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 39
Joined: Sun Oct 02, 2016 17:16

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by Maruti »

Ertiga elegant akomodasi lebih baik, karena suatu saat akan merasakan betapa pentingnya kursi baris ketiga.
kerubim
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 44
Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 10:52

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by kerubim »

Kayaknya mayoritas saran ke ertiga gx elegant..

Sip deh, saya tinggal cari unit yang masih kinyis2..
inrandomthoughts
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 130
Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2014 2:26

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by inrandomthoughts »

Kalo hasil googling GC ertiga 187mm vs jazz 160mm.. jazz kalo diisi full+barang lebih resiko kena polisi tidur..

Fun to drive menang jazz, style saya lebih suka jazz, tp kalo udh urusan keperluan weekend bersama keluarga, 3 rows seat menjadi penting sih. Apalagi kalo bawa golf bag atau sepeda kalo pakai jazz jok harus dilipat, berarti cuma sisa baris depan aja. Kalo ertiga masih kesisa 2 baris,
IG: @inrandomthoughts
Siegfried
Newbie
Newbie
Posts: 13
Joined: Wed Jul 27, 2016 1:51

Re: Budget 150 jt second jazz S 2013 vs ertiga gx elegant 2014

Post by Siegfried »

vote for jazz..
selain kelemahannya GC rendah , gampang gasruk..
soal kenyamanan, kelegaan space, handling, fun to drive ini menang jazz, selain itu untuk keluarga kecil ( 4 orng )
gini aja , mending test Drive , rasain bedanya nyetir di jazz dengan r3.. rasain fellnya , powernya ...
selain itu jazz produksi 2013 ini untuk adalah generasi terakhir sebelum keluar new jazz, dimana soal interior masih OK gw bilang( makanya harus TD masuk ke mobilnya ), dibanding jazz keluaran 2014 keatas yg build quality interiornya ancur bgt..