Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.0 V

Mau review kendaraan yang ada? Silakan post disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.0 V

Post by campoeran »

Halo pembaca SM yang tercinta , ane beranikan memberikan review ( seadanya ) komparasi antara suv dan sedan ( mmg gak apple to apple ) tp moga2 berkenan dan maafkan jika review nubi jelek gak spt master2 review di sini :) .
ps . ini adalah review bdskan pemakaian pribadi sehari-hari .

Eksterior
Image
Image
Dari desain eksterior , rasanya biar gambar yang berbicara aje dah , tp kebetulan secara desain sama2 sporty elegan , gak terlalu ekstrim desainnya . Siluet bodi keduanya oke banget.
Somehow gue masih demen altis ane utk eksterior , mgkn krn gue yg demen ama sedan . Cm kurang demen pantatnya altis yg rada off dibanding sisi depannya , sedangkan grill depan cx5 kurang demen kalau aja pakai grillnya mazda6 , perfecto !

Interior
Image
Desain Interior keduanya bener2 simple dan a bit plain , which is i like it . Bahannya sama2 oke , ada softpad di atas .
Disini hampir semuanya mirip , cuma fit finishnya rapi cx5 , altis gap2 kurang rapi . Untuk paduan warna interior ane lebih demen ama altis . kalao aja cx5 bawahnya warna beige juga pasti oke atau joknya hitam full jadi bisa matching .

Image
2nd row , mirip2 spacenya tp dengan setingan sehari hari ane , cx5 lebih lega , karena bangku depan gak terlalu mundur dikarenakan kaki gue gak mentok setir . Sedangkan di altis posisi setir kl gue naekan gak enak , jadi bangku depan harus rada mundur sehingga 2nd row rada kurang lega .
Untuk posisi driving gue masih demen di altis tetapi untuk jok enak cx5 :) .


Fitur
Untuk fitur , rasanya altis ane yang tuwir udah cukup lengkap , dibekali dengan HID , auto leveling, padelpop , smart start/stop , lumbar , dvd , gps etc . Cukup bersaing dengan cx5 .
CX5 menang ada sunroof , AFS , Bose , VSC ( lupa namanya dlm mazda apa ) , Hill launch assist .
Sedangkan Altis menang DVD player , padelpop dan Navigasi .

Driving pleasure
Okay untuk driving pleasure , ga usah ditanya , CX5 menang telak ! Ane bener2 nubi , baru bisa merasakan setelah memakai cx5 - altis gantian selama 1mingguan . Handling CX5 serasa "hidup" walau masih ada limbung kalau nikuk tajam .
Sedangkan altis menang di bagian feel sedannya dan keempukan jika pas hajar lubang / poldur . Akan tetapi CX5 masih bisa ditolerir , entah ya kalau yang 19" . Dan kalau melalui jalan yang bergelombang altis buat mabok .
Gue blm pernah bawa CX5 ke lukot nih , kl altis udah sering , pernah SBY - Banyuwangi , capek banget megangin setirnya .
Untuk daily dalkot , altis gue masih merasa lebih nyaman ke penumpang , tarikannya juga lembut krn CVT tp ya gitu ... dull , padelpop aktif gue merasa kurang nendang juga .
O ya last thing , CX5 kalau dipacu 80km/h kok denger suara angin dari spion ya ? emang gitu ?

FC Altis lebih irit dikit 1:8.5-9.5
FC CX5 1:8-1:9
Semua pemakaian pakai Pertamax

Overall , CX5 masih di atas ALtis dalam hal driving pleasure , kalau penumpang gue nanyain anak gue yg kecil dia demen cx5 sih cm awalnya dia ngomong suka altis , ada sebabnya krn ada DVD playernya jadi bisa lihat kartun :big_biglaugh: .

tambahan review long term pemakaian altis 2011 , 57K KM .
- Aki ganti sekali
- Ban udah ganti
- Pernah ada trouble di bagian steer rack di tahun pertama tp diganti langsung
- Problem bagasi gak bisa dibuka dari dalam , masih terjadi sampai skrg tp udah jarang
- Rattle di bagian belakang yg muncul stlh th1 , dan gak bisa dibenerin sampai sekarang
Selain itu fine2 aja dan gak ada rewel2nya , moga2 bisa pakai awet sampe 3-4th lagi .

Mazda CX5
(+ )
Body SUV , tinggi , gak takut gasruk
Warna oke banget !
Fitur Lengkap

(- )
Perawatan susah , belum apa2 udah pada swirl , mgkn akan segera nubi kasih paint protection
DRL seperti mata sakit , bahasa jawanya ketek'en
USB gak bisa resume :frm_bang_head:
gak ada padelpop
gak ada DVD player dan navigasi
ada suara angin kalau jalan >80km/h

Altis
(+ )
Demen banget desainnya timeless
Fitur komplit plit
Nyaman
Reliable

(- )
Lampu belum proyektor
Handling payah
Belum ada VSC
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by montirangin »

mantep sharingnya om..thanks
User avatar
WongZo
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2083
Joined: Tue Dec 17, 2013 15:06
Location: Bandung

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by WongZo »

Nice deh om :big_exellent:
Klw perbandingan tenaganya gmn om ?
User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by campoeran »

Kalau tarikan setan , megang cx5 sih om.
User avatar
sukribo
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 547
Joined: Fri Sep 06, 2013 3:44
Location: Surabaya

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by sukribo »

Hahahaa ... akhirnya om campoeran gatel juga bikin review yah :big_biglaugh:
mantap om komparasinya :mky_02:
**************
The only reason I'm giving it five stars is because I can't give it 14 - Clarkson
yeodi
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 333
Joined: Tue Jul 30, 2013 8:15
Daily Vehicle: Accord_cp2

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by yeodi »

padelpop apaan om?? sori ane nubi..ahahaha... :mky_01:

Btw, Really good Review.. :mky_02:
jason28
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 645
Joined: Tue Dec 31, 2013 4:38

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by jason28 »

Nice compare om mix eh om campuran :mky_02:
Kalo desain, gw lbh condong ke Altis, entah lbh suka aja :upss:
btw altisnya type v yak om?soalnya di judul trit cm "review komparasi cx5 touring & (long term) Altis 2." :ungg:
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by amfibi »

yeodi wrote:padelpop apaan om?? sori ane nubi..ahahaha... :mky_01:

Btw, Really good Review.. :mky_02:
Paddle shift om... :mky_01:

BTW nice review om campuran :mky_02:

Naksir altisnya nih lama2, yg FL kyk punya om campuran plg cakep dah :mky_02:
User avatar
AD74YA
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 9769
Joined: Thu Jun 12, 2008 19:51
Location: Pasar Minggu, Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: Toyota Alphard

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by AD74YA »

Newbie numpang pejwan..
Anda sudah TEST DRIVE belum?...
hariy
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2269
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2013 1:03
Location: 06º 35' 42" LS 110º 40' 18" BT

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by hariy »

wah..wah..wah...jangankan ripiunya, liat mobilnya saja saya sudah angkat jempol (yg tangan saja, bukan kaki-bau). mobil & ripiunya sippp, om campoeran !! :off_good_job:
User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by campoeran »

sukribo: iya review ala nubi. Jason: iya tipe v, udah diedit momod keknya . Amfibi: he eh keren eksterior yg fl tipe v ketolong grilnya. Om helm: ampun makasih udah mampir. Maaf ini reply di nokia jadul gue.
poik99
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 229
Joined: Fri Aug 19, 2011 16:23
Location: Jakarta

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by poik99 »

nice om reviewnya :mky_08:

tapi itungannya cx-5 lebih irit donk ya kan kelasnya 2,5liter dibanding 2liter :mky_04:

ada beberapa yang bilang untuk tarikan di bawah cx-5 2000cc itu kurang tarik apa kalo yang di 2,5 enak tarikan bawah and atas? :big_smile]
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16668
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by ChZ »

wih mantap ripiunya oom campoeran... :mky_02:

ntar KuSeM di bulan agustus bawa altisnya yak... penasaran dgn altis generasi ini belom pernah nyetir euy... :ungg: Altis generasi paporit ane dah nih... tjakep! :mky_02: apalagi yang 2.0V...

sayang rear suspensionnya torsion beam spt hatch <250jeteng... :ungg: tapi surprisingly, lebih nyaman dibanding Civic FD :ungg:

anyway, mungkin CX-5 nya terasa sedikit limbung gegara beli yang Touring 17" oom? ban tebel mmg kurang napak di aspal.

soalnya ane nyetir yang 2.5 GT dulu enak bener kayak hatch dah... bodyroll jauh menang dibanding RE apalagi Harrier... :big_slap:

apalagi CX-5 sedan a.k.a Mazda6... udah kaya Miata 4-doors aja... :mky_02: Zoom Zoom bebeh!
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
montirangin
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 6271
Joined: Thu May 22, 2014 3:38

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by montirangin »

GzT beda ya bukan cuman sensor2 aja?
ola_comoesta
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 832
Joined: Sun May 19, 2013 10:00

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by ola_comoesta »

nice review om ahahhaahaha, mendadak muncul nih komparasinya..sipo sipo sipo

untuk angin ane sendiri belum ngerasain, coba besok lewat jalan tol hehehehe

@montirangin : LDWS, HBC dan velg aja bedanya
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16668
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by ChZ »

yang ane maksudkan itu beda ukuran velg.

velg 19" dengan ban Toyo Proxes4 profil tipis jelas punya keuntungan di handling yang lebih baik...

note : seingat ane Touring 17" bannya bukan Proxes. mungkin itu jg pengaruh ke gripnya...
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
User avatar
nugroho bagor
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5507
Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2011 22:48
Location: All over the world
Daily Vehicle: Kijang Innova D4D

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by nugroho bagor »

:frm_salut: wiih mantap, review long termnya om :cupss:
User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by campoeran »

poik99 wrote:nice om reviewnya :mky_08:

tapi itungannya cx-5 lebih irit donk ya kan kelasnya 2,5liter dibanding 2liter :mky_04:

ada beberapa yang bilang untuk tarikan di bawah cx-5 2000cc itu kurang tarik apa kalo yang di 2,5 enak tarikan bawah and atas? :big_smile]
Bawah atas oke kok :) .
Chz wrote:wih mantap ripiunya oom campoeran... :mky_02:

ntar KuSeM di bulan agustus bawa altisnya yak... penasaran dgn altis generasi ini belom pernah nyetir euy... :ungg: Altis generasi paporit ane dah nih... tjakep! :mky_02: apalagi yang 2.0V...

sayang rear suspensionnya torsion beam spt hatch <250jeteng... :ungg: tapi surprisingly, lebih nyaman dibanding Civic FD :ungg:

anyway, mungkin CX-5 nya terasa sedikit limbung gegara beli yang Touring 17" oom? ban tebel mmg kurang napak di aspal.

soalnya ane nyetir yang 2.5 GT dulu enak bener kayak hatch dah... bodyroll jauh menang dibanding RE apalagi Harrier... :big_slap:

apalagi CX-5 sedan a.k.a Mazda6... udah kaya Miata 4-doors aja... :mky_02: Zoom Zoom bebeh!
Kalau gak disandera bisa2 aja haha . Iya kalau nyamannya oke banget kok , sayang handlingnya payah . Iya mgkn gara2 17" cm gak terlalu limbung kok .

@ola : hehe iya coba om kl kenceng dan matiin lagu . Di gue mayan jelas suaranya.

@ nugroho : thanks
pdm
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 424
Joined: Fri May 11, 2012 3:26

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by pdm »

Kalo mau grill cx5 dengan garis horizontal seperti mazda6 bisa kok om :D

Yg 17 pake yokohama geolander. Kalo diliat speed ratingnya V, harusnya grip udah bagus ya? Cmiiw.
cs2jakartaselatan
New Member of Junior Mechanic
New Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 17
Joined: Sat Jun 07, 2014 1:56

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by cs2jakartaselatan »

aduh CX5 merahnya keren bgt
User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by nescafe »

pdm wrote:Kalo mau grill cx5 dengan garis horizontal seperti mazda6 bisa kok om :D

Yg 17 pake yokohama geolander. Kalo diliat speed ratingnya V, harusnya grip udah bagus ya? Cmiiw.
kalau yang 19 pakai toyo proxes R36 ya oom? dibuat spesifik untuk cx5 ya kalau tak salah :D
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
User avatar
maskopat
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14444
Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2008 9:28
Location: in your heart

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by maskopat »

nescafe wrote:
pdm wrote:Kalo mau grill cx5 dengan garis horizontal seperti mazda6 bisa kok om :D

Yg 17 pake yokohama geolander. Kalo diliat speed ratingnya V, harusnya grip udah bagus ya? Cmiiw.
kalau yang 19 pakai toyo proxes R36 ya oom? dibuat spesifik untuk cx5 ya kalau tak salah :D
jadinya GV atau CX5 om? :e-think:
Dark Brownies with Cappuccino
Red and Gold
Lime Green
User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by nescafe »

maskopat wrote:
nescafe wrote:
pdm wrote:Kalo mau grill cx5 dengan garis horizontal seperti mazda6 bisa kok om :D

Yg 17 pake yokohama geolander. Kalo diliat speed ratingnya V, harusnya grip udah bagus ya? Cmiiw.
kalau yang 19 pakai toyo proxes R36 ya oom? dibuat spesifik untuk cx5 ya kalau tak salah :D
jadinya GV atau CX5 om? :e-think:
rahasiaa............. :ngacir:
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
rudykakashi
Member of Junior Mechanic
Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 34
Joined: Wed Jun 12, 2013 2:35

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by rudykakashi »

mobil favorit gw nih keduanya, walaupun skrg pake cx5 2.0 tetep aja liat altis 2.0V (2010-2013) tetep noleh... andaikan dulu bs ngambil altis pasti gk bakal jadi beli cx5.. jd ttp bersyukur skrg dptnya yg paling puas, gk kuat pake sedan buat jalanan Jakarta..

mantap om mobil2nya, selera ente sama kyk ane :big_exellent: :big_grin:

andaikan bs punya 2 mbl pasti pengen punya sama kyk digarasi om campoeran, tp posisi altis bs kegeser sm mazda6 kodo skrg :big_biglaugh:
User avatar
campoeran
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2782
Joined: Thu Oct 17, 2002 10:44
Location: surabaya rek

Re: Review komparasi CX5 2.5 Touring & (Long term ) Altis 2.

Post by campoeran »

Waduh , nama juga sama nih , rudy ....... zzzz
Iya skrg drpd mid sedan altis, civic mending lsg 6 atao teana aja deh .