Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Butuh saran untuk membeli kendaraan untuk pribadi, keluarga ataupun kerja? Silakan dibahas disini...

Moderators: Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze, akbarfit

aisya
Visitor
Visitor
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon Mar 09, 2015 8:21

Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by aisya »

Mohon bantuannya para SMers, saya adalah penyimak setia SM, mengingat kebutuhan operasional kerjaan yang menuntut kendaraan segala medan tetapi tetap mobil modis ala ibu-ibu, minta pendapat SMers pilihan mobil yang tepat antara livina xgear matic atau SX4, rute harian saya 30-50 km maklum jadi sales ke Majlis ta'lim/arisan ibu2, sebelumnya saya pengguna avanza matic karena rada gedean jadi nyari yang agak comfort, :off_ladies:
User avatar
FRD
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1805
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 15:00
Location: Malang
Daily Vehicle: 2010 Nissan XTrail T31

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by FRD »

sx4 dong, ambil yg udah facelift aja sekalian...
:big_smoking:
User avatar
amfibi
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8594
Joined: Mon Dec 31, 2012 5:45
Location: Central Park, JakBar

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by amfibi »

Comfort yah ... SX4 jauh dari kata comfort sih, rada kebanting2 :ungg:

Livina xgear paling cocok mah buat nyaman berhubung suspensinya empuk, ato ertiga juga nyaman lho dibawa + dinaikinnya :mky_02:
Rutenya ke daerah mana2 aja btw?
yeodi
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 333
Joined: Tue Jul 30, 2013 8:15
Daily Vehicle: Accord_cp2

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by yeodi »

Comfort sih livina.. Tp tenaganya parah banget dan sparepart mahaal abiss..

Kalo ane, go for sx4 facelift 2010 ke atas.. Ane pake yg 2008 aja maknyuss setelah carbonclean dan isi shell super terus.. :big_exellent:
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16683
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by ChZ »

Nuntutnya "kendaraan segala medan"... SX4 udah paling cocok.

Kebetulan sehari - hari pakai buat "kendaraan segala medan" juga... uda lulus uji dalem kota luar kota dipake cukup intens... odometer read 78k KM...

Kaki-kaki awet? Check.
Ground clearance tinggi? Check.
Tenaga mumpuni? Check.

Keras? Saya rasa kalau dibanding Avanza ya jauh enak SX4... kalau masih ngerasa keras coba ganti shock absorber ke merek Kayaba seri Excel-G... Saya kmaren ganti itu sih nggak ngerasa keras sama skali yah... :e-whistle: malah bantingannya pas buat saya dibanding shock ori. 1.5jt sepasang.

X-Gear sih cuma Livina dikasih popok... ngga da kemampuan nerjang segala medan... nol gede.

Mau hajar segala medan jangan pake Livina series... dipake normal dalem kotaan aja keluhannya seabreg apalagi "segala medan"... Ada 2 orang temen sama - sama pake GL XV 2010 beda transmisi... GL 2010 MT baru jalan 40k sudah minta jajan shock... yang 2010 AT udah jajan lower arm malah. Yang 2010 MT pakenya alusan cuma dalem kota... 2010 AT dipake perang.

SX4 sih kemaren 78ribu shock kiri belakangnya masih 50%... yang kanan belakang matek total yah... Tapi saya ganti 2 2nya sekalian toh odo sudah segitu :mrgreen:
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
User avatar
nyotnyet
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1702
Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2009 6:23
Location: surabaya
Daily Vehicle: CX-5 GT Soul Red

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by nyotnyet »

Kalo ts mau uji kesabaran ya beli GL ajah..hahahaha...
Papa saya pake GL baru beli taun lalu...nyaman emang bener, cuma buat harga segitu, fitur agak menyedihkan, jok ga ada fitur naik turun (ertiga aja ada), seat belt ga bisa naik turun, ban bawaan HWS berisik...
Ga bisa lari, mau dipindah ke mode apa aja juga percuma, cuma suara mesin tambah kenceng
Kalo sx4 sih royal banget kasih fiturnya...kmrn pernah naik punya chris sih masih masuk oke sih bantingannya menurut saya...hehehehe

Soul Red zoom zoom
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by DOHC »

GL berpopok utk kendaraan perang harian ?? :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03:
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
suvmania
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 261
Joined: Fri May 10, 2013 11:33

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by suvmania »

DOHC wrote:GL berpopok utk kendaraan perang harian ?? :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03:
Seperti ada bau2 trauma di postingan mod klep ini
:ngacir:
Daily Tol Japek Beater :big_smoking:

Even Plate: 2018 RU1 SE
Odd Plate : 2008 W204 C230
User avatar
Mamang555
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1083
Joined: Fri Aug 16, 2013 7:51

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by Mamang555 »

SX4 jelas

Btw ini dua2nya harganya anjlok ya..? Kena dibawah cepek ga ya?
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16683
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by ChZ »

nyotnyet wrote:Kalo ts mau uji kesabaran ya beli GL ajah..hahahaha...
Papa saya pake GL baru beli taun lalu...nyaman emang bener, cuma buat harga segitu, fitur agak menyedihkan, jok ga ada fitur naik turun (ertiga aja ada), seat belt ga bisa naik turun, ban bawaan HWS berisik...
Ga bisa lari, mau dipindah ke mode apa aja juga percuma, cuma suara mesin tambah kenceng
Kalo sx4 sih royal banget kasih fiturnya...kmrn pernah naik punya chris sih masih masuk oke sih bantingannya menurut saya...hehehehe
Padahal waktu bos mapia naik itu shock belom saya ganti :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03:
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
User avatar
grandis_GT
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1553
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2012 12:36
Location: Riau

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by grandis_GT »

Ane vote sx4 matic , lebih relible , apalagi TS cewe , gak perlu takut tiba" trouble di jalan :ungg:
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by DOHC »

suvmania wrote:
DOHC wrote:GL berpopok utk kendaraan perang harian ?? :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03: :mky_03:
Seperti ada bau2 trauma di postingan mod klep ini
:ngacir:
@ raissa : trauma yg dalam rais.... dalam sekali...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
madcat015
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 13579
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 8:52
Location: Surabaya

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by madcat015 »

Lipicong X-Gear vs SX-4? Lebih baik SX-4... Bahkan vs Juke aja SX-4 lebih baik urusan kenyamanan, akomodasi, dan power. Juke kabin sempit, suspensi keras naujubile, dan kursi kecil. Ane sampe heran, itu batumakam otak nya ke mana sampe masukin Juke alih2 Qashqai. :big_slap:

Satu lagi: biaya servis nya murah abis itu SX-4... Hal ini yg bikin ane nempel 6 taon sama bengkel resmi Sijuki. Lovely price, outstanding services!

So, jauhi batumakam at any cost... :ngacir:
Obey the mahakitteh. :big_cat:
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by DOHC »

@ mods whiskas :

dulu2 puji joke... skrg blg jauhin... pasti krn ad faktor caca nya....

dasar kucing...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
FRD
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1805
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 15:00
Location: Malang
Daily Vehicle: 2010 Nissan XTrail T31

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by FRD »

DOHC wrote:@ mods whiskas :

dulu2 puji joke... skrg blg jauhin... pasti krn ad faktor caca nya....

dasar kucing...
caca mau ganti yasir trd mods, makanya itu joke skrg dihujat :mky_03:
:big_smoking:
User avatar
didietkeren
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 491
Joined: Fri Jun 29, 2007 10:23

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by didietkeren »

Harga keduanya kisaran berapa yach?
User avatar
madcat015
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 13579
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 8:52
Location: Surabaya

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by madcat015 »

DOHC wrote:@ mods whiskas :

dulu2 puji joke... skrg blg jauhin... pasti krn ad faktor caca nya....

dasar kucing...
Image

................................. :ngacir:


FRD wrote:
DOHC wrote:@ mods whiskas :

dulu2 puji joke... skrg blg jauhin... pasti krn ad faktor caca nya....

dasar kucing...
caca mau ganti yasir trd mods, makanya itu joke skrg dihujat :mky_03:
BatuMakam = approve to be cursed of coz :big_smoking:
Obey the mahakitteh. :big_cat:
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by DOHC »

FRD wrote:
DOHC wrote:@ mods whiskas :

dulu2 puji joke... skrg blg jauhin... pasti krn ad faktor caca nya....

dasar kucing...
caca mau ganti yasir trd mods, makanya itu joke skrg dihujat :mky_03:
sudah ane duga...

dasar kucing nya caca...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 16683
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by ChZ »

madcat015 wrote:Lipicong X-Gear vs SX-4? Lebih baik SX-4... Bahkan vs Juke aja SX-4 lebih baik urusan kenyamanan, akomodasi, dan power. Juke kabin sempit, suspensi keras naujubile, dan kursi kecil. Ane sampe heran, itu batumakam otak nya ke mana sampe masukin Juke alih2 Qashqai. :big_slap:

Satu lagi: biaya servis nya murah abis itu SX-4... Hal ini yg bikin ane nempel 6 taon sama bengkel resmi Sijuki. Lovely price, outstanding services!

So, jauhi batumakam at any cost... :ngacir:
Biaya servis murah darimane? Ongkos murah... onderdil mahal mah.

Filter oli cepek ceng itu murah ? :frm_bang_head:
Shock blakang harganya sama kaya CR-V 2.4...
Brake pads harganya sama kayak Accord....

murah opone :frm_bang_head: Dimana-mana gw saranin substitute aja pakai aftermarket... lebih worth.

Gw si uda jauhin bengkel resmi karena trauma... malah trauma sama yang pusat. Beres tukang PHP dan kerjanya gak beres pula.

Sisuka selain Carry, APV, K-engine lineups (K10, K12, K14) mah mahal.... M-engine sama J-engine ongkosnya considered mahal dibanding competitornya.
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
User avatar
FRD
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1805
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 15:00
Location: Malang
Daily Vehicle: 2010 Nissan XTrail T31

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by FRD »

ChZ wrote:
madcat015 wrote:Lipicong X-Gear vs SX-4? Lebih baik SX-4... Bahkan vs Juke aja SX-4 lebih baik urusan kenyamanan, akomodasi, dan power. Juke kabin sempit, suspensi keras naujubile, dan kursi kecil. Ane sampe heran, itu batumakam otak nya ke mana sampe masukin Juke alih2 Qashqai. :big_slap:

Satu lagi: biaya servis nya murah abis itu SX-4... Hal ini yg bikin ane nempel 6 taon sama bengkel resmi Sijuki. Lovely price, outstanding services!

So, jauhi batumakam at any cost... :ngacir:
Biaya servis murah darimane? Ongkos murah... onderdil mahal mah.

Filter oli cepek ceng itu murah ? :frm_bang_head:
Shock blakang harganya sama kaya CR-V 2.4...
Brake pads harganya sama kayak Accord....

murah opone :frm_bang_head: Dimana-mana gw saranin substitute aja pakai aftermarket... lebih worth.

Gw si uda jauhin bengkel resmi karena trauma... malah trauma sama yang pusat. Beres tukang PHP dan kerjanya gak beres pula.

Sisuka selain Carry, APV, K-engine lineups (K10, K12, K14) mah mahal.... M-engine sama J-engine ongkosnya considered mahal dibanding competitornya.
maklumin aja, itu kucing kebiasa servis di mazda yg abisnya lebih dari sa tiao :ngacir:
:big_smoking:
User avatar
imingwahyudi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2972
Joined: Sat Nov 30, 2013 15:30
Location: 万隆, 印度尼西亚

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by imingwahyudi »

hem..... :mky_03:

saya cenderung pilih Livina X-Gear...bukan yang ada embel embel grand di depannya...(short wheel base xgear), personally karena lebih nyaman untuk harian...ada satu hal annoying di SX4 AT yang terkadang bikin malas...shift point yang terkadang tinggi...misal larikan 40...mesin tetap nahan gigi tinggi...mau dikocok pun gak turun :big_slap: mau gak mau kencangkan sedikit baru naik ke gigi lebih tinggi :big_bored: ...itu si yang bikin saya prefer Livina over SX4 :big_think:
User avatar
ibar78
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1292
Joined: Sat Aug 04, 2007 11:06
Location: mtg, jakarta
Daily Vehicle: toyota fans boys

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by ibar78 »

sx-4 oranye...eye catching banget..... :big_grin:
:popcorn:
User avatar
nyotnyet
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1702
Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2009 6:23
Location: surabaya
Daily Vehicle: CX-5 GT Soul Red

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by nyotnyet »

imingwahyudi wrote:hem..... :mky_03:

saya cenderung pilih Livina X-Gear...bukan yang ada embel embel grand di depannya...(short wheel base xgear), personally karena lebih nyaman untuk harian...ada satu hal annoying di SX4 AT yang terkadang bikin malas...shift point yang terkadang tinggi...misal larikan 40...mesin tetap nahan gigi tinggi...mau dikocok pun gak turun :big_slap: mau gak mau kencangkan sedikit baru naik ke gigi lebih tinggi :big_bored: ...itu si yang bikin saya prefer Livina over SX4 :big_think:
Apanya yg dikocok? Situ nyetir atau ngapain sih?
*kabur

Soul Red zoom zoom
User avatar
madcat015
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 13579
Joined: Thu Nov 29, 2012 8:52
Location: Surabaya

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by madcat015 »

nyotnyet wrote:
imingwahyudi wrote:hem..... :mky_03:

saya cenderung pilih Livina X-Gear...bukan yang ada embel embel grand di depannya...(short wheel base xgear), personally karena lebih nyaman untuk harian...ada satu hal annoying di SX4 AT yang terkadang bikin malas...shift point yang terkadang tinggi...misal larikan 40...mesin tetap nahan gigi tinggi...mau dikocok pun gak turun :big_slap: mau gak mau kencangkan sedikit baru naik ke gigi lebih tinggi :big_bored: ...itu si yang bikin saya prefer Livina over SX4 :big_think:
Apanya yg dikocok? Situ nyetir atau ngapain sih?
*kabur
Kalo dikocok bukannya makin ngaceng ya? Abis lepas, baru turun...










*rev enjin nya...* ......... :ngacir:
Obey the mahakitteh. :big_cat:
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 27647
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Milih mana grand livina Xgear cvt atau SX4 matic

Post by DOHC »

kocok ?? livina ??

le se3xy time ?? impossible, apalagi di lipina...
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir: