Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Otak2ik peforma mesin? Silakan bahas disini...

Moderators: akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze

lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

paidjho wrote: Sat Nov 18, 2017 14:13Yg dimaksud mungkin target nya seperti apa Om? Daily driven, rally, circuit, drag, time attack?
Brapa hp, brapa detik, atau hanya modif aja?

Imho, untuk efisiensi biasanya force induction lebih baik. Jgn lupa reinforce internal dan aspek breaking & handling...

Ati2 aja, sky is the limit...
Thank you for your reply!

Braking and handling udah secure, udah saya upgrade, brembo 6pot/4pot, coilovers ST Suspension (by KW GmbH Germany), Cusco full kit chassis strengthening, and many more yg details on my build are available di forum sebelah.
Handling and braking aspects are always yg pertama saya mods sebelum ke engine tuning buat mobil apa aja yg saya pake sekarang atau yg dulu pernah pakai.

The car is my daily drive (yg extreme lagi rencana bangun di mobil beda), internals sekalian jalan tergantung nanti mau seberapa gain, apa NA atau Force induction, etc.

Agreed. Force induction paling bagus from cost to power gain ratio, dari discussions diatas ini masuk consideration jg and a decision will be made when all information are gathered successfully, whether going NA or force induction.

Btw ini paidjo yg di forum sebelah?
doge
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 748
Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2016 14:54

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by doge »

mobilnya daily drive. ->info trivial

suspensi pke coilover, rem 6pot4pot, chassis strengthening ->ini modif yg sdh dilakukan

Tujuannya masih agak samar.... mmg ada bilang 'yg extreme di mobil beda' ; tp bwt orang kyk sy klo udh gnti internal, apalagi smpe gnti blok, overbore etc itu udh extreme modifnya..

trus target hp torsi (gain) nti aja ngikutin... lha kan susah. Modif mesin itu parameter utamanya ya gain itu. Sama budget constraint. Lha klo itu g ada smua mw nyaranin gmn coba... kan jd kyk nanya ke gebetan... 'km mw apa?' 'Mau bahagia' 'bahagia gmn? 'Pokoknya bahagia'
:ngacir:
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

doge wrote: Sat Nov 18, 2017 15:48 mobilnya daily drive. ->info trivial

suspensi pke coilover, rem 6pot4pot, chassis strengthening ->ini modif yg sdh dilakukan

Tujuannya masih agak samar.... mmg ada bilang 'yg extreme di mobil beda' ; tp bwt orang kyk sy klo udh gnti internal, apalagi smpe gnti blok, overbore etc itu udh extreme modifnya..

trus target hp torsi (gain) nti aja ngikutin... lha kan susah. Modif mesin itu parameter utamanya ya gain itu. Sama budget constraint. Lha klo itu g ada smua mw nyaranin gmn coba... kan jd kyk nanya ke gebetan... 'km mw apa?' 'Mau bahagia' 'bahagia gmn? 'Pokoknya bahagia'
Okay, valid points, saya coba jawab and dissect one by one ya, moga2 lebih clear:
1. Engine output saya mau ke >265hp om crank after tuning which means sama seperti 3GRFSE specs, and buat weekly morning runs lebih bisa keep up dengan yg lain lebih baik lagi. Sebenernya dengan remap bisa dapet ke >280hp on crank iirc setelah naik ke 3.0L
2. 6pot/4pot brakes: kenapa saya ganti ke yg ini? Simply karena stock brakes menurut saya sangat kurang mendukung buat highspeed braking.
3. ST coilover: menurut saya kalau mau beli coilover dan budget ada, beli yg baik. Of course Perrin, öhlins, KW pasti jauh lebih baik tapi itu di luar budget saya
4. Chassis stiffening: stock mark x chassis rigidity nya kurang gigit menurut selera saya. Tapi ya, toleransi tiap orang beda beda..

Apa masi enak buat dipake harian? Bole test duduk after saya pulang ke indonesia lagi in early January 2018. Apakah lebih stiff vs. oem? Dengan mods saya, of course, tapi sekali lagi, bole saya buktikan dengan doge test ride nanti early January setelah saya balik indonesia lagi..

Back to aim: as mentioned in point #1 above, “1. Engine output saya mau ke >265hp om crank after tuning which means sama seperti 3GRFSE specs, and buat weekly morning runs lebih bisa keep up dengan yg lain lebih baik lagi. Sebenernya dengan remap bisa dapet ke >280hp on crank iirc setelah naik ke 3.0L“
doge
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 748
Joined: Mon Jan 18, 2016 14:54

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by doge »

Ok om imaleke...

Klo targetnya segitu yaa...

Klo msh pke mesin asli kyknya hrs agak ekstrim modifnya... (bs bore stroke up dll kyk ide om: mmg agak ruwet... hrs cr parts, bengkel yg bs ngerjain, mungkin trial error, dll
ato klo mw agak simpel (g pke overbore overstroke) ya pke turbo sm piston gnti low compression biar bs boost gede (klo ada yg bikin), oya parts lain jg hrs dicek... apa msh bs pke std ato hrs gnti)
Tp klo pke turbo itu biasanya agak peaky mesinnya (tp max powernya lbh gede dr SC)... klo mw yg agak linear ya supercharger..

Klo mw hati tenang ya beli mesin 3GR.. trus tinggal mikiri ecunya gmn...

Goodluck modifnya
:ngacir:
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

doge wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2017 4:35 Ok om imaleke...

Klo targetnya segitu yaa...

Klo msh pke mesin asli kyknya hrs agak ekstrim modifnya... (bs bore stroke up dll kyk ide om: mmg agak ruwet... hrs cr parts, bengkel yg bs ngerjain, mungkin trial error, dll
ato klo mw agak simpel (g pke overbore overstroke) ya pke turbo sm piston gnti low compression biar bs boost gede (klo ada yg bikin), oya parts lain jg hrs dicek... apa msh bs pke std ato hrs gnti)
Tp klo pke turbo itu biasanya agak peaky mesinnya (tp max powernya lbh gede dr SC)... klo mw yg agak linear ya supercharger..

Klo mw hati tenang ya beli mesin 3GR.. trus tinggal mikiri ecunya gmn...

Goodluck modifnya
Thank you for your reply! :frm_tumbright:

Kebetulan last night saya wechat call dengan salah satu colleagues saya and he said similar things as you mentioned, right afterwards langsung cari info internal 4GRFSE vs. 3GRFSE. I’m back to the study 📖 and reseach stage now and will inform you on the updates. Sharing is caring :frm_tumbleft:
As for now, seems saya leaning ke naekin cc but kita lihat gimana cost nya karena after further study and researches saya will have a detail information on the internal components, such as, piston heads, crankshaft, etc
Thank you :frm_tumbleft:
efact
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Full Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 520
Joined: Thu Jan 12, 2017 2:11

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by efact »

lmaleke wrote: Fri Nov 17, 2017 15:58
Means kl single turbo jgn kegedean AF nya and kl bisa yg Variable Geometry buat kompensasi turbo lag ya oom? :e-think:

Nah masalah twin or single, kl twin bragging rights nya ciamik “yo, check out my twin turbos” :mrgreen: :e-dance: hahahahhaa tapi musti pake yg kecilan ya or perhaps yg kecil...

Make sense sih logical thinking nya, thank you and kalo ada reference reputable garage/shop/bengkel yg sanggup custom works bole oom mohon petunjuk.. lumayan buat banding2 and tanya tanya dulu yg jelas :frm_tumbleft: :frm_tumbright:
Err.. variable turbo di bensin masi sangat jarang kayaknya om.. kalopun ada mgkin harganya bakalan mahal.. Banget.

Tp balik lg yg spt om bilang sndiri ruang mesinnya udh padet banget, kayaknya twin turbo lebih masuk akal berarti ga pusing ngakalin header merge nya,

Tp.. barusan baca mobil ini utk daily drive.. kalo saya, preferensi saya lho, utk daily kayaknya n/a is the best sih.. Turbo mgkin peak nya jauh lebih tinggi, tp lag nya itu menyebalkan,, :mrgreen:
Kalo soal bengkel, sebener preference masing2 sih om trgantung cocok2an om sama si empunya bengkel imho, semua pasti ada plus minus nya..
Dulu wktu main mesin saya sndiri seringnya ke arrow motorsport di daerah tebet, cmn kayaknya skrg bgkel nya dah ga terbuka umum deh..
2011 Hyundai ix35
2001 BMW E39 530i
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

efact wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2017 11:27 Err.. variable turbo di bensin masi sangat jarang kayaknya om.. kalopun ada mgkin harganya bakalan mahal.. Banget.

Tp balik lg yg spt om bilang sndiri ruang mesinnya udh padet banget, kayaknya twin turbo lebih masuk akal berarti ga pusing ngakalin header merge nya,

Tp.. barusan baca mobil ini utk daily drive.. kalo saya, preferensi saya lho, utk daily kayaknya n/a is the best sih.. Turbo mgkin peak nya jauh lebih tinggi, tp lag nya itu menyebalkan,, :mrgreen:
Kalo soal bengkel, sebener preference masing2 sih om trgantung cocok2an om sama si empunya bengkel imho, semua pasti ada plus minus nya..
Dulu wktu main mesin saya sndiri seringnya ke arrow motorsport di daerah tebet, cmn kayaknya skrg bgkel nya dah ga terbuka umum deh..
Thank you for your reply! :frm_tumbleft:
Iya after long discussions over wechat call last night with one of my friends, sepertian better go with NA for simplicity-sake and for the time being. Turbo bisa aja tapi karena sama sekali belum ada yg pernah ngejalanin so pasti musti lewatin numerous trial and errors yg ahirannya lebih banyak di shop instead of di jalanan di bejek :mrgreen:

Nanti kl mau force induction lagi, turbo or supercharger, better cari used evo or used civic fd..

Will keep you posted on any result! :frm_tumbright:

Thank you
User avatar
paidjho
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1207
Joined: Tue Jan 05, 2016 0:58
Location: Jakarta

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by paidjho »

lmaleke wrote:
paidjho wrote: Sat Nov 18, 2017 14:13Yg dimaksud mungkin target nya seperti apa Om? Daily driven, rally, circuit, drag, time attack?
Brapa hp, brapa detik, atau hanya modif aja?

Imho, untuk efisiensi biasanya force induction lebih baik. Jgn lupa reinforce internal dan aspek breaking & handling...

Ati2 aja, sky is the limit...
Thank you for your reply!

Braking and handling udah secure, udah saya upgrade, brembo 6pot/4pot, coilovers ST Suspension (by KW GmbH Germany), Cusco full kit chassis strengthening, and many more yg details on my build are available di forum sebelah.
Handling and braking aspects are always yg pertama saya mods sebelum ke engine tuning buat mobil apa aja yg saya pake sekarang atau yg dulu pernah pakai.

The car is my daily drive (yg extreme lagi rencana bangun di mobil beda), internals sekalian jalan tergantung nanti mau seberapa gain, apa NA atau Force induction, etc.

Agreed. Force induction paling bagus from cost to power gain ratio, dari discussions diatas ini masuk consideration jg and a decision will be made when all information are gathered successfully, whether going NA or force induction.

Btw ini paidjo yg di forum sebelah?
Bukan Om, saya gak punya account di lapak lain, cuman di SM aja...
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

paidjho wrote: Sun Nov 19, 2017 15:48 Bukan Om, saya gak punya account di lapak lain, cuman di SM aja...
Okay..
User avatar
exball
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 84
Joined: Fri Sep 12, 2014 4:59

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by exball »

Gimana kelanjutan Stroke Up 4gr-fse nya om?
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

exball wrote: Sun Dec 09, 2018 15:23 Gimana kelanjutan Stroke Up 4gr-fse nya om?
Jadinya engine swap, and it is in progress
User avatar
mamat
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 179
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 12:03
Location: +62

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by mamat »

lmaleke wrote: Mon Dec 17, 2018 11:01
Jadinya engine swap, and it is in progress
Swap pakai apa om Imaleke?
powered by B20VTEC kick in yoo :mky_08:
User avatar
marzoochi
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 575
Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 0:15
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: Toyota MarkX

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by marzoochi »

:big_exellent: Mantap oom Lmaleke, can’t wait to see the new engine and dynotest
User avatar
b8099ok
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 2794
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:14
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2020 All New Xpander Pickup

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by b8099ok »

Throw that engine away. Install 1VDFTV auto 👌
FWD + RWD + 4WD = :big_cat:
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

mamat wrote: Mon Dec 17, 2018 13:51 Swap pakai apa om Imaleke?
Toyota engine jg but nanti ya sampe all is done baru reveal.. nothing yg blings or harbringer tapi cukup significant bump in output... not bad buat drive to kantoor ahhahahaha
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

b8099ok wrote: Mon Dec 17, 2018 15:32 Throw that engine away. Install 1VDFTV auto 👌
I have my reasons on my engine selection other than the landcruise engine you said.. :emo-photo:
User avatar
mamat
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 179
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 12:03
Location: +62

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by mamat »

lmaleke wrote: Tue Dec 18, 2018 7:50
Toyota engine jg but nanti ya sampe all is done baru reveal.. nothing yg blings or harbringer tapi cukup significant bump in output... not bad buat drive to kantoor ahhahahaha
Ditunggu cerita lebih lanjutnya, semoga tebakan saya ttg type mesin yang dipilih benar.
powered by B20VTEC kick in yoo :mky_08:
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

mamat wrote: Tue Dec 18, 2018 12:57
lmaleke wrote: Tue Dec 18, 2018 7:50
Toyota engine jg but nanti ya sampe all is done baru reveal.. nothing yg blings or harbringer tapi cukup significant bump in output... not bad buat drive to kantoor ahhahahaha
Thank you for your kind wishes :big_okay:
Ditunggu cerita lebih lanjutnya, semoga tebakan saya ttg type mesin yang dipilih benar.
Kl bole tau tebakan oom mamat apa hayo.. which engine I selected? :big_cat:
jivos
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1960
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 9:04
Location: jkt

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by jivos »

pk 3GR FE ya um ato langsung naik k 2GRFSE?
basis pk mark x y um?

kira" worthed mana um ambil unit mark x + swap engine + upgrade FL look VS ambil unit Lexus is300 nd gen 2008 dg 3grfenya atopun w204 c300?
4 wheels move the body, 2 wheels move the soul.
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

jivos wrote: Wed Dec 19, 2018 3:50 pk 3GR FE ya um ato langsung naik k 2GRFSE?
basis pk mark x y um?

kira" worthed mana um ambil unit mark x + swap engine + upgrade FL look VS ambil unit Lexus is300 nd gen 2008 dg 3grfenya atopun w204 c300?
Is this Ivan Arnell kah? :big_smile]
Either engine yg oom jivos mentioned bisa dari base apa aja
Nah ini sepertian yg di signature oom, you should drive a car that you really like.. karena worthy to spend or not beda2 tiap org.. in short, kacamata org beda2.. :frm_salut:

Lexus is300 (asean specs) xe2 alias 2nd gen alias gse chassis code, juga okay, cuman cari yg mulus aja.. kapan hari saya ketemu but sama sekali ga mulus.. and yg mulus ga mau dilepas, fair enough karena enak dipake nya :e-pray:

Nah compare to benzo ya again, selera and both are good. there is something about German made cars that separate them from the Japanse made cars..

Saya beli mark x karena it is a good platform buat dimaenin ini bakalan jadi the next altezza.. and di japan udah mulai.. plus ini mobil jarang banget di indo..
User avatar
mamat
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 179
Joined: Thu Jul 23, 2009 12:03
Location: +62

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by mamat »

lmaleke wrote: Wed Dec 19, 2018 2:28
Kl bole tau tebakan oom mamat apa hayo.. which engine I selected? :big_cat:
Tebakan saya jz series or uz series
powered by B20VTEC kick in yoo :mky_08:
jivos
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1960
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2008 9:04
Location: jkt

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by jivos »

lmaleke wrote: Wed Dec 19, 2018 14:26
Is this Ivan Arnell kah? :big_smile]
Either engine yg oom jivos mentioned bisa dari base apa aja
Nah ini sepertian yg di signature oom, you should drive a car that you really like.. karena worthy to spend or not beda2 tiap org.. in short, kacamata org beda2.. :frm_salut:

Lexus is300 (asean specs) xe2 alias 2nd gen alias gse chassis code, juga okay, cuman cari yg mulus aja.. kapan hari saya ketemu but sama sekali ga mulus.. and yg mulus ga mau dilepas, fair enough karena enak dipake nya :e-pray:

Nah compare to benzo ya again, selera and both are good. there is something about German made cars that separate them from the Japanse made cars..

Saya beli mark x karena it is a good platform buat dimaenin ini bakalan jadi the next altezza.. and di japan udah mulai.. plus ini mobil jarang banget di indo..
bukan ivan arnell um, xixixixi...
nebak 2gr n 3gr krn msh dlm satu family dg 4gr, jd ngga perlu pusing bikin dudukan mounting baru, posisi engine bs dipastikan tetap di kondisi centre (kiri-kanan, atas-bwh,depan-blkg)
buat org" detail macem um pasti noticed bobot/balance peletakan engine yg tdk pas pd saat swap bikin dudukan mounting br, akan berpengaruh ke behave/driving dynamic mblny, bkn sekedar gaining more hp. :mrgreen:

ah nice to know why picked mark x.:frm_tumbright:

sy pk glassnya...premium flavor on the ground of reliabilty, buat menyisihkan bbrp pilihan.

he he iya japs kek android hp yg lbh friendly buat dbongkar pasang vs europe yg mdl iphone ngga bs kawin silang.
4 wheels move the body, 2 wheels move the soul.
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

jivos wrote: Thu Dec 20, 2018 14:51bukan ivan arnell um, xixixixi...
nebak 2gr n 3gr krn msh dlm satu family dg 4gr, jd ngga perlu pusing bikin dudukan mounting baru, posisi engine bs dipastikan tetap di kondisi centre (kiri-kanan, atas-bwh,depan-blkg)
buat org" detail macem um pasti noticed bobot/balance peletakan engine yg tdk pas pd saat swap bikin dudukan mounting br, akan berpengaruh ke behave/driving dynamic mblny, bkn sekedar gaining more hp. :mrgreen:

ah nice to know why picked mark x.:frm_tumbright:

sy pk glassnya...premium flavor on the ground of reliabilty, buat menyisihkan bbrp pilihan.

he he iya japs kek android hp yg lbh friendly buat dbongkar pasang vs europe yg mdl iphone ngga bs kawin silang.
Gabung GRiD jg ya? Anyway, you read me correct and since aim nya itu tetep jadi daily drive ya many things must be taken into consideration.
furthermore, additional matters I take into accounts is the relative simplicity of this project :big_peace:

Nti gw pasti provide updates when the time comes, step by step update.. :big_cat:
xtr40rd1n4rym4n
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2084
Joined: Sat Dec 31, 2005 4:16

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by xtr40rd1n4rym4n »

lmaleke wrote: Tue Dec 25, 2018 11:57

Gabung GRiD jg ya? Anyway, you read me correct and since aim nya itu tetep jadi daily drive ya many things must be taken into consideration.
furthermore, additional matters I take into accounts is the relative simplicity of this project :big_peace:

Nti gw pasti provide updates when the time comes, step by step update.. :big_cat:
:big_exellent: :big_exellent:
Ijin nyimak ya bozzcoco panutanku...
:mky_02:
lmaleke
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Full Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 98
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2015 3:48

Re: Stroke Up 4GR-FSE

Post by lmaleke »

xtr40rd1n4rym4n wrote: Tue Dec 25, 2018 12:23 :big_exellent: :big_exellent:
Ijin nyimak ya bozzcoco panutanku...
:mky_02:
Cocohmevvah bantu doa moga2 lancar :big_peace: