Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Mau mengadakan polling? Silakan post disini...

Moderators: akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze

Mobil paling tidak aman

Datsun Go
22
27%
Datsun Go+
41
50%
Honda Brio Satya
4
5%
Karimun Wagon R
1
1%
Toyota Agya
3
4%
Daihatsu Ayla
4
5%
Toyota Avanza / Veloz
2
2%
Daihatsu Xenia
1
1%
Daihatsu Gran Max
1
1%
Daihatsu Luxio
2
2%
Nissan Evalia
1
1%
 
Total votes: 82

User avatar
nyotnyet
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1702
Joined: Tue Aug 18, 2009 6:23
Location: surabaya
Daily Vehicle: CX-5 GT Soul Red

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by nyotnyet »

Vote datsun go/go+

Sodara ada yg punya, dibawa ke Bali, cangar dalam waktu bersamaan..hasilnya kaki2nya harus cek di nissan, barusan denger akinya keabisan air aki...gile...
Servisnya di dealer nissan plg hebat sesurabaya...if you know what i mean...hahahaha

Soul Red zoom zoom
User avatar
ChZ
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 15500
Joined: Tue Oct 08, 2013 14:30
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Civic FK4

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by ChZ »

DOHC wrote:+1 masing2 utk barang generik nya batu makam...

bkin malu nama besar datsun aj... mending cepetan bangkrut dehh... ini batu makam drpd aneh2 bkin sampah... mending perbaikin tuh kualitas kaki2 batu makam series nya...

btw, ad yg sebut2 panther... jd inget dl perna hajar bajaj pake panther kotak ane.... ntuh bajaj lgs remuk ga karuan, panty ane cuman melesek bemper besi nya plus grill pecah dan sdikit penyok di kap... malah DC ganti rugi si bajaj lebi mahal dr btulin si panty...

@ mods chz : walaupun model sama... tp spek dll nya beda, bahkan ampe welding spot nya beda mods... at least itu yg perna disampein om NR entah di tret apa... lupa ane... kl ga salah bahas soal granmax, evalia versi impor dan indo punya... waktu itu ybs katanya ampe bawa2 sample dr indo utk kes nya di europe sana...
Hmmm welding spots pengaruh ke kekuatan / rigiditas sasis...

Kalo memang welding spotsnya beda.... berarti safety mobil CKD mostly questionable dong. Exc. Euros yang memang cuma rakit doank alias SKD.

Jadi safety mobil di Indonesia cuma bisa diukur dari err... jumlah kecelakaan x fatalities... Karena ngga da lembaga independen yang ngetes.

Well penghematan listrik dan elektroda las... Mungkin itu bagian dari cost reduction...
1997 E39 M52B28
2017 FK4 L15B7
Salvanost
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2926
Joined: Fri Dec 14, 2012 13:44

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by Salvanost »

jujur aja...
ngenes rasanya lihat mobil under 100jt dibawa ngebut diatas 140kpj...
DOHC
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Full Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 26894
Joined: Sat Jan 31, 2009 17:48
Location: in engine bay with carbonfibre as roof

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by DOHC »

ChZ wrote:
DOHC wrote:+1 masing2 utk barang generik nya batu makam...

bkin malu nama besar datsun aj... mending cepetan bangkrut dehh... ini batu makam drpd aneh2 bkin sampah... mending perbaikin tuh kualitas kaki2 batu makam series nya...

btw, ad yg sebut2 panther... jd inget dl perna hajar bajaj pake panther kotak ane.... ntuh bajaj lgs remuk ga karuan, panty ane cuman melesek bemper besi nya plus grill pecah dan sdikit penyok di kap... malah DC ganti rugi si bajaj lebi mahal dr btulin si panty...

@ mods chz : walaupun model sama... tp spek dll nya beda, bahkan ampe welding spot nya beda mods... at least itu yg perna disampein om NR entah di tret apa... lupa ane... kl ga salah bahas soal granmax, evalia versi impor dan indo punya... waktu itu ybs katanya ampe bawa2 sample dr indo utk kes nya di europe sana...
Hmmm welding spots pengaruh ke kekuatan / rigiditas sasis...

Kalo memang welding spotsnya beda.... berarti safety mobil CKD mostly questionable dong. Exc. Euros yang memang cuma rakit doank alias SKD.

Jadi safety mobil di Indonesia cuma bisa diukur dari err... jumlah kecelakaan x fatalities... Karena ngga da lembaga independen yang ngetes.

Well penghematan listrik dan elektroda las... Mungkin itu bagian dari cost reduction...
makanya itu ane blg mods...

datsun itu mending cepetan dibkin bangkrut lg dehh.... kasian, datsun nama besar d jaman dl... ancur oleh ide konyol nya si ghosn skrg... mending mreka mikir nama baru dehh ktimbang ngancurin reputasi jaman dl...

batu makam kl mau bkin mobil berkualitas sebenernya bsa koq... ntuh lipina series contohnya... scara idea sehh purrfect bgt utk mpv.... plg nyaman utk city cruiser... cuman entah knapa parts yg dipake entah buatan pabrik rumahan di pedalaman cungkwo sana... makanya end up nya kaya gt... bcara soal safety pun jg not bad ini livina... rem cakram dgn diameter ckup terbesar di jaman nya... struktur rangka yg ckup terkuat lagi2 di kelas nya... bahkan crash test doi diatas duo kaleng...

mungkin si ghosn lg lelah mimpin batu makam, makanya jd caur gt
numpang lewat aja.... :ngacir: :ngacir:
adityawei
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 713
Joined: Mon Nov 30, 2015 1:44
Location: Surakarta
Daily Vehicle: Toyota Kijang Innova V D4D 2013

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by adityawei »

ChZ wrote:
Hmmm welding spots pengaruh ke kekuatan / rigiditas sasis...

Kalo memang welding spotsnya beda.... berarti safety mobil CKD mostly questionable dong. Exc. Euros yang memang cuma rakit doank alias SKD.

Jadi safety mobil di Indonesia cuma bisa diukur dari err... jumlah kecelakaan x fatalities... Karena ngga da lembaga independen yang ngetes.

Well penghematan listrik dan elektroda las... Mungkin itu bagian dari cost reduction...
ditambah lagi penghematan tenaga kerja, "subsidi" dana produksi, pengurangan kualitas material dll jg bisa mempengaruhi gak sih.. :mky_08:
DOHC wrote:
makanya itu ane blg mods...

datsun itu mending cepetan dibkin bangkrut lg dehh.... kasian, datsun nama besar d jaman dl... ancur oleh ide konyol nya si ghosn skrg... mending mreka mikir nama baru dehh ktimbang ngancurin reputasi jaman dl...

batu makam kl mau bkin mobil berkualitas sebenernya bsa koq... ntuh lipina series contohnya... scara idea sehh purrfect bgt utk mpv.... plg nyaman utk city cruiser... cuman entah knapa parts yg dipake entah buatan pabrik rumahan di pedalaman cungkwo sana... makanya end up nya kaya gt... bcara soal safety pun jg not bad ini livina... rem cakram dgn diameter ckup terbesar di jaman nya... struktur rangka yg ckup terkuat lagi2 di kelas nya... bahkan crash test doi diatas duo kaleng...

mungkin si ghosn lg lelah mimpin batu makam, makanya jd caur gt
mobil2 tua datsun yg sedan termasuk kuat2 lho kalo dilihat2.. jaman dulu menangan banget kan ini datsun jadul.. termasuk kuat dikelasnya dan dijamannya..
2013 Toyota Grand New Kijang Innova V 2.5
User avatar
daftar
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1510
Joined: Sun Nov 09, 2014 15:35

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by daftar »

vote Daihatsu Xenia aja,
Gran max/luxio saya anggap sebagai angkot atau mobil travel jd bukan mobil pribadi so ga perlu dinilai
:ngacir:
User avatar
sandal
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3688
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2014 1:13

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by sandal »

Saya pilih DatGo semuanya


Alasannya ya begitulah :big_dunno:
2017 Ignis

2021 HRV SE Improvement
User avatar
b8099ok
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 2794
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:14
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2020 All New Xpander Pickup

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by b8099ok »

Semua mobil itu tidak aman,... Kalo drivernya brain dead atau brainless,... :ngacir:
FWD + RWD + 4WD = :big_cat:
User avatar
sandal
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3688
Joined: Thu Jul 03, 2014 1:13

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by sandal »

b8099ok wrote:Semua mobil itu tidak aman,... Kalo drivernya brain dead atau brainless,... :ngacir:
+1
Ditambah pengemudi juga heartless itu juga bikin tidak aman :ngacir:
2017 Ignis

2021 HRV SE Improvement
User avatar
b8099ok
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 2794
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:14
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2020 All New Xpander Pickup

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by b8099ok »

sandal wrote:
b8099ok wrote:Semua mobil itu tidak aman,... Kalo drivernya brain dead atau brainless,... :ngacir:
+1
Ditambah pengemudi juga heartless itu juga bikin tidak aman :ngacir:
:ngacir:
FWD + RWD + 4WD = :big_cat:
User avatar
FRD
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 15:00
Location: Malang
Daily Vehicle: 2010 Nissan XTrail T31

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by FRD »

b8099ok wrote:
sandal wrote:
b8099ok wrote:Semua mobil itu tidak aman,... Kalo drivernya brain dead atau brainless,... :ngacir:
+1
Ditambah pengemudi juga heartless itu juga bikin tidak aman :ngacir:
:ngacir:
ngequote cuma ada emot ngacir, ane warn :big_smoking:










....................................... :ngacir:
:big_smoking:
User avatar
b8099ok
SM Specialist
SM Specialist
Posts: 2794
Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2009 4:14
Location: Jakarta
Daily Vehicle: 2020 All New Xpander Pickup

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by b8099ok »

FRD wrote:
b8099ok wrote:
sandal wrote: +1
Ditambah pengemudi juga heartless itu juga bikin tidak aman :ngacir:
:ngacir:
ngequote cuma ada emot ngacir, ane warn :big_smoking:










....................................... :ngacir:
Lemu :ngacir:
FWD + RWD + 4WD = :big_cat:
User avatar
imingwahyudi
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 2968
Joined: Sat Nov 30, 2013 15:30
Location: 万隆, 印度尼西亚

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by imingwahyudi »

b8099ok wrote:
FRD wrote:
b8099ok wrote: :ngacir:
ngequote cuma ada emot ngacir, ane warn :big_smoking:










....................................... :ngacir:
Lemu :ngacir:
Dutty :ngacir:
User avatar
FRD
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1801
Joined: Tue Aug 26, 2014 15:00
Location: Malang
Daily Vehicle: 2010 Nissan XTrail T31

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by FRD »

imingwahyudi wrote:
b8099ok wrote:
FRD wrote: ngequote cuma ada emot ngacir, ane warn :big_smoking:










....................................... :ngacir:
Lemu :ngacir:
Dutty :ngacir:
bang sat & mingky :ngacir:
:big_smoking:
User avatar
Ryan Steele
SM Moderator
SM Moderator
Posts: 4422
Joined: Tue May 29, 2007 12:23
Location: Ke mana pun tugas negara membawaku

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by Ryan Steele »

Gendut?.........
no signature
User avatar
Mitsubishisale
SM Affiliate
SM Affiliate
Posts: 593
Joined: Tue Sep 23, 2014 11:46
Location: Jl.Danau Sunter Utara Blok B No 14

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by Mitsubishisale »

FRD wrote:
imingwahyudi wrote:
b8099ok wrote: Lemu :ngacir:
Dutty :ngacir:
bang sat & mingky :ngacir:
Biar rame aja :ngacir:
Menerima Pemesanan Kendaraan MITSUBISHI dan Merk Lain nya :big_deal:

More Info :

Xl : 0877-7778-1377 ( WA + Tlp )


:big_cat:
ak4ng
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 10469
Joined: Sun Aug 15, 2010 7:20
Location: smi, bdg, jawa barat
Daily Vehicle: Unimog

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by ak4ng »

Numpang lewat aja ............. :glodak:
REAR-WHEEL DRIVE TO KEEP YOU MOVING FORWARD

INFO KOPI KLIK: KOPI MALABAR
GriffinMelet
New Member of Senior Mechanic
New Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 169
Joined: Thu Jun 11, 2015 5:26
Location: Semarang
Daily Vehicle: Venturer_HR-V_Vario 125

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by GriffinMelet »

ak4ng wrote:Numpang lewat aja ............. :glodak:
Lewat bayar :big_chicken:








:ngacir:
Share the driving pleasure :ngacir:

'21 2GD A/T
'18 RU1
User avatar
solar_kerosen
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3050
Joined: Mon Apr 02, 2007 1:45
Location: Indonesia

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by solar_kerosen »

imansyx wrote:menurut saya paling ga aman justru datsun go, rangkanya ga kuat intrusi ke kabin parah banget di crash test

itu mobil sblm dijual dites dulu gak ya sama batu makam safetynya :big_dunno:

curhat aja, avanza old yg semua orang bilang kaleng kerupuk tapi saya sekeluarga pernah tabrakan waktu mudik 6 tahun lalu ampe jadi HB tuh mobil, semua penumpang depan blkg pake seatbelt cuma luka gores2 kena pecahan, dasbor maju & trim pintu pecah semua, tangki bbm aman ga pecah

yg parah engsel pintu kalah jadi semua orang merayap ke pintu supir satu2nya yang bisa dibuka

:ngacir: itu supir yang nyetir, gw duduk di sebelah doi :big_dunno:
Image

Cm mau komentar pic of the year. :wkkk:
Performa mesin berlipat ganda setiap 30 tahun
dimsum87
New Member of Junior Mechanic
New Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 17
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2015 3:50

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by dimsum87 »

Ane pernah baca berita, pasar indonesia tidak memperdulikan mbl fitur yg baik, termasuk rangkanya. Asal murah pasti dibeli walau fitur minum.
Ini adalah miris menurut saya.... Harua dirubah mindset seperti ini.
Saya aja memilih fitur terutama keselamatan yg bagus, harga mahal bagi saya ngga apa2 asal selamat.
User avatar
fizrmen
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 1050
Joined: Sun Aug 30, 2015 12:49
Location: BSD (Bogor Sana Dikit)
Daily Vehicle: Civic FD2

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by fizrmen »

Ini asli RushTer gaada yg sebut? Emg DatGo separah itu ya... Blm pernah coba sih....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
2009 Honda Civic FD2
2015 Honda CR-V 2.4l A/T
User avatar
Bulgogi
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
New Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 916
Joined: Tue Mar 08, 2016 12:16

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by Bulgogi »

piggypig77 wrote:mumpung ada yg ngomongin panther,bbrp mggu lalu saya liat pjs di tabrak panther kotak (angkot) depan mangdu n yg pasti under 50 speednya,kap panther kelipet tp ga nyampe stgh n pjs mulus2 aja,jadi bingung katanya mbl jaman dlu kuat ga gampang penyok kok ini kebalikan :big_think:
Badak vs badak :mky_03:
Btw masa sih om panther selemah itu?
Panther engkong ane aja tabrak pohon, pohonnya tumbang :ngacir:
User avatar
Rampaiger
New Member of Junior Mechanic
New Member of Junior Mechanic
Posts: 15
Joined: Fri Mar 18, 2016 10:45

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by Rampaiger »

Bulgogi wrote:
piggypig77 wrote:mumpung ada yg ngomongin panther,bbrp mggu lalu saya liat pjs di tabrak panther kotak (angkot) depan mangdu n yg pasti under 50 speednya,kap panther kelipet tp ga nyampe stgh n pjs mulus2 aja,jadi bingung katanya mbl jaman dlu kuat ga gampang penyok kok ini kebalikan :big_think:
Badak vs badak :mky_03:
Btw masa sih om panther selemah itu?
Panther engkong ane aja tabrak pohon, pohonnya tumbang :ngacir:
Setahu ane, emang bagian belakang mobil itu lebih rigid dari bagian depan for pedestrian safety reason.
Jadi misalkan kondisinya dibalik, pjs yg nabrak panther, menurut ane yg remuk ya si pjs tuh. CMIIW :big_think:
kunaskun
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 3964
Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 8:16

Re: Mobil Paling Tidak Aman Versi SM 2015

Post by kunaskun »

datsun go+ si emang ga aneh berantakan, di indihe sampe 0 rating crash test. sayang padahal platformnya udah bagus pake Nissan Renault B platform setara juke dan march, yg ratingnya bagus. mungkin platform doang tapi material dan penempatan reinforced ga pas...