ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Segala mobil tipe SUV (2WD/4WD). (Cherokee, Terios, Rush, dll).

Moderators: akbarfit, Ryan Steele, sh00t, r12qiSonH4ji, avantgardebronze

User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by nescafe »

esh wrote:Saya menunggu review dari rekan SMers yang sdh beli. Sepertinya X-Trail tidak bisa dianggap remeh. Kalau tipe yang lama saya kurang suka radius putar minimumnya agak besar.
siy hansen udah beli pak esh, bsa langsung ditanyakan pada sang pemilik.. :D
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
User avatar
Hansen
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 16497
Joined: Tue Apr 03, 2007 14:24

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by Hansen »

nescafe wrote:
esh wrote:Saya menunggu review dari rekan SMers yang sdh beli. Sepertinya X-Trail tidak bisa dianggap remeh. Kalau tipe yang lama saya kurang suka radius putar minimumnya agak besar.
siy hansen udah beli pak esh, bsa langsung ditanyakan pada sang pemilik.. :D
eits... :e-naughty: gw cuman managernya, bukan pemilik... :mrgreen:


wakakakakaka! :mrgreen:
Image
Risol1
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5870
Joined: Thu Jul 05, 2007 4:21

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by Risol1 »

lucky_strike_21 wrote:wew, ntar kalo emang bener terbukti xtrail lebih bagus yg menyesal banyak banget tuh huehuehue
paling taun depan suv terlaris jadi xtrail lagi, 2 taun lg crv facelift yg menang crv lagi... dan terus menerus mreka gantian menang...
.................... :ngacir:
mungkin nyesel soal kualitas dan reliability sih engga karena CRV juga sama2 bagus.
tapi kalo soal selera model mungkin bisa nyesel juga
User avatar
DigitALL
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 9595
Joined: Thu May 15, 2003 16:12
Location: Indonesia

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by DigitALL »

Yang saya suka dari X-TRAIL yaitu:
- Xtronic CVT. Performa mesin lebih maksimal kalau kita suka ngebut cukup pakai tiptronicnya dan perpindahan speed lebih smooth.
- Kualitas dashboard bagus, dilapis lagi jadi tidak keliatan murahan.
- Jok lebih empuk dan suspensi lebih nyaman

Yang saya tidak suka dari X-TRAIL:
- Model biasa saja, padahal major change. Sekilas seperti minor change.
- Jok baris kedua tidak bisa digeser maju mundur sehingga legroom tidak seluas CR-V

Yang saya suka dari CR-V:
- Model eksterior menarik dan interior lebih mewah
- Ruang legroom dan headroom lebih luas

Yang saya tidak suka dari CR-V:
- Jok kurang empuk dan suspensi juga lebih keras dari X-Trail
GTR
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5168
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by GTR »

kalo ga salah powernya xtrail sekarang direduce jadi 170hp => same as crv; utk "menyesuaikan" level bbm di indo?
User avatar
Abu2
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8765
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 8:46
Location: +6261
Daily Vehicle: just a bike

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by Abu2 »

@GTR : yup bener. kalo baca di autobild, liat spek nya katanya dikurangi 10hp untuk menyesuaikan dgn BBM indo, walau minimum requirementnya Ron 90
User avatar
andy1800
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8285
Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 19:52
Location: djakarta

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by andy1800 »

^^ weits, reduced ??..:o ..... kenyataan yg "membanggakan"..... :e-whistle:
pdhal dulunya pemilik (dan calon pemilik) X-trail (lbh memilihnya & lalu) membanggakan mobilnya, krn sentakan nya yg (lebih) garang drpd CRV...
ttg reduce kegarangan ini, kira2 seberapa byk yg akan memilih utk mundur teratur ya.... dibanding dg yg berbondong2 me-mau-i nya.... ?
LAJUR KANAN... HARAP DISTERILKAN!

Image
GTR
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5168
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by GTR »

ga gitu efek kalo cuma turun 5.5% secara harusnya juga diimbangi refinement sektor lain utk model gen baru ini, driving mode patterns; & belum tau data torsi nya yg mungkin saja lebih besar dari yg lalu.
CVT nya ini lebih efisien transfer tenaga juga, bisa jadi CRV yg 5a/t kalah performanya.
User avatar
Abu2
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8765
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 8:46
Location: +6261
Daily Vehicle: just a bike

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by Abu2 »

tertulis , at least minum RON 90, jatuh2 nya ya pertamax juga tuh...
GTR
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5168
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by GTR »

bisa campur premium dong 50(yg 88):50(yg 92)..
User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by nescafe »

or premium + OB..
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
User avatar
Abu2
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8765
Joined: Tue Jun 12, 2007 8:46
Location: +6261
Daily Vehicle: just a bike

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by Abu2 »

nescafe wrote:or premium + OB..

premium + Office Boy ? :glodak: :glodak: :ngacir: :ngacir:
User avatar
nescafe
Member of Mechanic Master
Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 14333
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2008 3:18
Location: jakarta

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by nescafe »

Abu2 wrote:
nescafe wrote:or premium + OB..

premium + Office Boy ? :glodak: :glodak: :ngacir: :ngacir:
premium + Obat Batuk (biar mobilnya ga batuk2 gituh) :mrgreen: :mrgreen: :mrgreen:
Permisii :ungg: ............................. :ngacir:
User avatar
rambokampung
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 277
Joined: Wed Jun 18, 2008 12:37
Location: Kampungnya Rambo

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by rambokampung »

Taxi CRV neh, hebat jg CRV dah jadi taxi di Jerman berarti dah mayan teruji ketangguhannya, seperti vios di Indo. Mesin 2200cc turbo diesel i-CTDi 140 PS at 4,000 rpm Torsi 340 Nm di 2200 rpm. 0-100km 10,3 second FC 6.5 l/100 km Price €19,990

Image
n1ho
Visitor
Visitor
Posts: 2
Joined: Mon Aug 18, 2008 10:13

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by n1ho »

Kalo gue lebih milih CRV karena new xtrail bodinya menurut gw kurang menarik dan terkesan kotak dan terlalu besar
koolrider
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 235
Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 4:29

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by koolrider »

Klo gw 2-2nya aja deh . CRv buat gw-X trail buat yg dirumah.... :mrgreen: :glodak:
melvel
Visitor
Visitor
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Aug 07, 2008 2:54

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by melvel »

kalo di banding escape vs crv gimana ya? Lg binun nih mau ambil yg mana. Escape mau keluar yg baru tp nga tau modelnya lebih ok apa nga
User avatar
andy1800
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 8285
Joined: Mon Mar 24, 2008 19:52
Location: djakarta

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by andy1800 »

^ nampaknya, (silakan) check (sekilas) di Bookmark ini >>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =34&t=8052
sempat ada perbandingannya....semoga cocok, & silakan bahas disana..
sedangkan kalau dirasa perlu, silakan bikin New Topic ttg perbandingannya kedua mobil tsb.
andy1800 wrote:Bagi yg menginginkan pertimbangan utk membeli CR-V (terutama bekas), berikut ini Bookmarknya :

wuih, ternyata udah banyak bener ya, dibahas...tp kok msh bbrp kali muncul thread yg sama persis yaa.. :mrgreen:
aniwei, nampaknya CR-V memang small SUV yg paling populer dibahas di SM... disamping X-trail...
bahkan mgkn diatas medium SUV: Fortuner, & Everest.

Sebenarnya kumpulan thread ini bisa jg sbg dokumentasi Facelift atau perkembangan Generasi mobil tsb.
bahasan ttg CR-V ini hanya yg berhubungan lansgung, dan agak langsung... ada yg berhubungan tidak langsung, nggak gw masukin.
.........................

# [Tanya] CRV tipe lama (2000/2001) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=3697
# CRV 2.4L and X-Trail 2.0L >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1688
# CRV built-up thn 2000 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1888
# CRV 2002- on euro(altezza) taillight >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1078
# Honda CRV facelift >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1236
# Roof Rack CRV >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1100
# Honda Luncurkan New CRV 2004 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... f=12&t=552
# HPM luncurkan CR-V 2.4 liter >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=1827
# X-TRAIL lebih nyaman dari CR-V ! >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... f=12&t=590
# Ford Escape vs Honda Cr-V vs Nissan X-Trail >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... f=12&t=351
# minta pendapat crv, xtrail, dan fortuner >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=6654
# Tahun 2005, Tahun Pertarungan Honda CRV dan Nissan X-Trail >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=2108
# CRV -X- FORTUNER -X- X-TRAIL >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=3066
# Budget 250-300 jt untuk SUV >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=2037
# Pasar SUV 2005 Milik Honda CR-V >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=3385
# Almost here : Next generation Honda CRV and Nissan X-Trail >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=3718
# CRV 2400cc boros atau tidak? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=5851
# mohon tanya konsumsi bbm utk new crv 2.0 dan 2.4L >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=7635
# Xtrail Vs CRV Vs Fortuner >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=2233
# newbie asking about build quality....Xtrail to CRV? >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=5223
# All New CRV sudah diproduksi di Karawang >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=4945
# Ask New CRV 07 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=6519
# CRV, best Selling Ute in US >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=5712
# Sekilas test drive CR V 2007 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=6059
# Design Bumper Depan New CRV >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=5615
# Seputar CRV >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=7437
# Komparasi Ban X-Trail, RAV, CRV MkII (215/65R16) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> http://www.serayamotor.com/diskusi/view ... =12&t=5700

.........................
oiya...katanya ada momod momod yg akan (atau udah) bikin kompilasi artikel2 SM ....in PDF .....mana yaa ....?
............. :ngacir: :ngacir:
LAJUR KANAN... HARAP DISTERILKAN!

Image
User avatar
DigitALL
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 9595
Joined: Thu May 15, 2003 16:12
Location: Indonesia

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by DigitALL »

Hasil test sebuah tabloid CR-V 2.0 M/T dan X-TRAIL 2.0 M/T. Suzuki Grand Vitara juga di test tapi menggunakan A/T jadi kurang imbang.
Hasilnya:
- CR-V sedikit lebih irit tapi akselerasi X-TRAIL sedikit lebih unggul (menurut saya dua2nya hampir tidak ada perbedaan signifikan soal konsumsi BBM dan performa). Kembali pada masalah selera saja.

Untuk versi CR-V 2.4L A/T dan X-TRAIL 2.5L A/T nya saya belum pernah baca.
User avatar
ZombiEE
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 11521
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2007 7:20

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by ZombiEE »

beda di harga jauh yah bro rupanya...kalo sama2 versi 2.0mt..buset harga nya beda 40jeti...
User avatar
dnz
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 214
Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 3:51

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by dnz »

soal harga.. pajak x-trail lebih murah daripada CR-V, soalnya X-trail diitungnya jenis mini/microbus, kalo CR-V tu jeep.. bole di cek di stnknya deh..
:drinking:
GTR
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Full Member of Mechanic Engineer
Posts: 5168
Joined: Thu Nov 22, 2007 10:26

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by GTR »

hah.. bener bisa diskriminasi kategori gitu di stnk? nah loh... koq bisa?
kalo gitu, pajak tahunannya jg murah dong..
User avatar
skylion
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 279
Joined: Wed Apr 11, 2007 8:03

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by skylion »

di forum sebelah ada yg bilang penyuka crv cowo2 feminim, small c*ck
kalo xtrail baru cowo macho yg big c*ck
emang bener seh hub langsungnya antara selera mobil -> penis size
(approved)

:beer:
User avatar
ZombiEE
New Member of Mechanic Master
New Member of Mechanic Master
Posts: 11521
Joined: Sat Mar 17, 2007 7:20

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by ZombiEE »

no comment deh bang,.itu uda offensive sekali
User avatar
dnz
Member of Senior Mechanic
Member of Senior Mechanic
Posts: 214
Joined: Wed Jan 31, 2007 3:51

Re: ALL NEW X-TRAIL vs ALL NEW CRV

Post by dnz »

@GTR iya, stlh gw liat pajak x-trail 2500cc = all new cr-v 2000cc

@skylion cr-v jg bagus kok modelnya.. tinggal pili aje lebih sering dipake kemana..